Prieto Nathalie, Zurcher Karine, Guyot Léa, Galia Perrine, Robinson Philip, Fernandez Arnaud, Askenazy Florence, Chauliac Nicolas, Vignaud Philippe
Centre Régional du Psychotraumatisme, Hôpital Edouard Herriot, Hospices Civils de Lyon, Lyon, France.
Cellule d'Urgence Médico-Psychologique, Hôpital Edouard Herriot, Hospices Civils de Lyon, Lyon, France.
Front Public Health. 2025 Jun 5;13:1494289. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2025.1494289. eCollection 2025.
In intimate partner homicides, children are confronted with multiple losses and become simultaneously a victim and the child of a murderer. These homicides have a very negative effects of these tragedies on these children There is a need to provide them early care, and this requires straightforward guidelines. The objective is to assess the feasibility of implementing such a feminicide protocol and to discuss, point-by-point, the difficulties of their application. It includes a series of 17 steps, from the commission of the offense to the end of 72 h hospitalization. Data regarding the completion of steps was to be collected for each of these situations. During the study period there were 4 intimate partner homicides; these involved 14 children. Overall, the protocol criteria were applied at a rate of 88.6%, 9/17 criteria where applied for each child. However, certain provisions, including a shorter duration of hospitalization, the absence of personal belongings, the lack of hearing the child witnesses and, above all, the restriction of visiting rights during hospitalization, are worth noting. Operational deviations of the protocol from the theoretical version are discussed. The present study reported encouraging results concerning the feasibility of the "femicide protocol" with the co-victim children, but the discrepancies between the protocol and the implementations reported in that study require to reflect about optimizations of the protocol and their potential influence on children's wellbeing. The recent extension of the protocol in the French national territory will provide the professionals concerned with opportunities to solve the remaining challenges.
在亲密伴侣杀人案件中,儿童面临多重损失,同时成为受害者和杀人犯的子女。这些杀人案件对这些儿童产生了非常负面的影响。需要为他们提供早期护理,这需要明确的指导方针。目的是评估实施此类杀害妇女案件协议的可行性,并逐点讨论其应用中的困难。它包括从犯罪发生到72小时住院结束的一系列17个步骤。要针对每种情况收集有关步骤完成情况的数据。在研究期间,发生了4起亲密伴侣杀人案件;涉及14名儿童。总体而言,协议标准的应用率为88.6%,每个儿童适用9/17项标准。然而,某些规定值得注意,包括住院时间较短、没有个人物品、没有听取儿童证人的陈述,最重要的是,住院期间探视权受到限制。讨论了协议与理论版本在操作上的偏差。本研究报告了关于“杀害妇女案件协议”对共同受害儿童可行性的令人鼓舞的结果,但该研究报告的协议与实施之间的差异需要思考协议的优化及其对儿童福祉的潜在影响。该协议最近在法国全国范围内的扩展将为相关专业人员提供解决剩余挑战的机会。