Fecher-Jones Imogen, Ainsworth Ben, Gan Tong J, Moonesinghe S Ramani, Shaw Andrew D, Grocott Michael P W, Levett Denny Z H
Department of Perioperative Care, University Hospital Southampton NHS Foundation Trust, Southampton, UK.
School of Psychology, Faculty of Environmental and Life Sciences, University of Southampton, Southampton, UK.
Anaesthesia. 2025 Sep;80(9):1115-1133. doi: 10.1111/anae.16648. Epub 2025 Jun 21.
Pre-operative group sessions incorporating patient education and behaviour change interventions, known as 'surgery schools', are becoming increasingly common before major elective surgery across the world. However, there is a lack of conclusive evidence regarding the effectiveness of surgery schools, and the development and delivery of these complex interventions lacks standardisation.
In collaboration with the Perioperative Quality Initiative, we aimed to develop evidence- and expertise-based consensus statements and recommendations regarding the definition, design, content, and outcomes of surgery schools. Thirty-two international multidisciplinary experts in surgery school and pre-operative preparation attended a series of virtual meetings based on a modified Delphi methodology. A systematic review and additional targeted literature searches were used to propose statements for the definition, design, content and outcomes of surgery schools. Statements and recommendations were discussed iteratively and refined in multiple rounds, until agreement was reached.
Consensus was reached on a definition of surgery school, as well as three statements and 18 recommendations in relation to: scope; outcomes; intervention development; delivery; inclusivity; and educational content of surgery schools. Seventeen areas were highlighted as priorities for future research.
These consensus statements and recommendations are intended to help clinicians and service managers who plan to develop and implement surgery schools. They may improve the quality of those programmes and help to standardise their content. We also hope that this work will influence government strategy and policy in relation to the design, delivery and funding of peri-operative optimisation pathways.
术前小组会议纳入患者教育和行为改变干预措施,即所谓的“手术学校”,在全球范围内的大型择期手术前越来越普遍。然而,关于手术学校的有效性缺乏确凿证据,而且这些复杂干预措施的开发和实施缺乏标准化。
与围手术期质量倡议组织合作,我们旨在就手术学校的定义、设计、内容和结果制定基于证据和专业知识的共识声明和建议。32名手术学校和术前准备方面的国际多学科专家参加了一系列基于改良德尔菲法的虚拟会议。通过系统综述和额外的针对性文献检索,提出了关于手术学校定义、设计、内容和结果的声明。声明和建议经过反复讨论,并在多轮中进行完善,直至达成共识。
就手术学校的定义以及与手术学校的范围、结果、干预措施开发、实施、包容性和教育内容相关的三项声明和18项建议达成了共识。突出了17个领域作为未来研究的重点。
这些共识声明和建议旨在帮助计划开发和实施手术学校的临床医生和服务管理人员。它们可能会提高这些项目的质量,并有助于使其内容标准化。我们还希望这项工作将影响政府在围手术期优化途径的设计、实施和资金方面的战略和政策。