Anan Hind, Al Hariri Moustafa, Hitti Eveline, Kobeissy Firas, Mufarrij Afif
American University of Beirut Medical Center, Department of Emergency Medicine, Beirut, Lebanon.
Qatar University College of Medicine, Tamayuz Simulation Center, QU Health Sector, Doha, Qatar.
West J Emerg Med. 2025 May 18;26(3):743-750. doi: 10.5811/westjem.21131.
The massive 2020 blast in Beirut, Lebanon, caused by improperly stored ammonium nitrate, was one of the most powerful non-nuclear explosions in history, Following the blast, head injuries emerged as a predominant presentation to the emergency department (ED). Blast-induced head injuries can lead to mild traumatic brain injuries (mTBI) mediated via primary blast overpressure without direct head trauma. The recovery process from mTBIs can be prolonged and affected by several factors. If symptoms persist for more than three months, patients should be evaluated for post-concussion syndrome (PCS). While clinical blast-injury studies have focused on repetitive blast exposure, this study evaluates a cohort exposed to a single blast. We hypothesized that a single blast exposure is sufficient to induce PCS symptoms similar to those exposed to repetitive blasts.
This cross-sectional study explores PCS in patients presenting to the ED of a tertiary-care center following the Beirut blast. Patients were identified through medical charts, contacted by phone, and consented to participate at least three months post-blast (beginning in November 2020). We used the Rivermead Post-Concussion Questionnaire (RPQ) to assess for PCS. We analyzed the association of PCS with patients and injury characteristics.
Of 370 patients presenting to the ED, 145 (58.5%) completed the study questionnaire. Mean age was 39.8 ± 15.4 years, and 40% were females. Head trauma (46.9%) was the most common presentation. A total of 112 patients (77.2%) met the criteria for PCS, with a median RPQ score of 25 (interquartile range 18.75). After adjusting for injury types and distance from the blast, younger patients (adjusted odds ratio [aOR] 0.972, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.947-0.998) and females (aOR 2.836, 95% CI 1.114-7.220) were more likely to suffer from PCS.
Our study revealed a remarkably high prevalence of PCS among survivors of the Beirut blast, with younger individuals and females disproportionately affected. This highlights the need for age- and sex-specific rehabilitation and support programs. However, the study was limited by incomplete patients records and contact information, leading to the exclusion of a significant number of patients who initially presented to the ED. Ultimately, this study underscores the crucial role of robust public health preparedness and specialized care pathways against future large-scale catastrophes. Further assessment, including neurobiomarker evaluation, will be conducted on these survivors.
2020年黎巴嫩贝鲁特发生的由储存不当的硝酸铵引发的大规模爆炸,是历史上最强烈的非核爆炸之一。爆炸发生后,头部受伤成为急诊科的主要就诊情况。爆炸所致头部损伤可导致轻度创伤性脑损伤(mTBI),其通过原发性爆炸超压介导,而无直接头部外伤。mTBI的恢复过程可能会延长,并受多种因素影响。如果症状持续超过三个月,应对患者进行脑震荡后综合征(PCS)评估。虽然临床爆炸伤研究主要关注重复性爆炸暴露,但本研究评估了一组单次爆炸暴露的人群。我们假设单次爆炸暴露足以诱发与重复性爆炸暴露者相似的PCS症状。
这项横断面研究探讨了贝鲁特爆炸后在一家三级医疗中心急诊科就诊患者中的PCS情况。通过病历识别患者,通过电话联系他们,并征得他们同意在爆炸后至少三个月(从2020年11月开始)参与研究。我们使用里弗米德脑震荡后问卷(RPQ)来评估PCS。我们分析了PCS与患者及损伤特征之间的关联。
在370名到急诊科就诊的患者中,145名(58.5%)完成了研究问卷。平均年龄为39.8±15.4岁,40%为女性。头部外伤(46.9%)是最常见的就诊情况。共有112名患者(77.2%)符合PCS标准,RPQ中位数得分为25(四分位间距18.75)。在对损伤类型和与爆炸的距离进行调整后,年轻患者(调整后优势比[aOR]0.972,95%置信区间[CI]0.947 - 0.998)和女性(aOR 2.836,95%CI 1.114 - 7.220)更易患PCS。
我们的研究显示,贝鲁特爆炸幸存者中PCS的患病率极高, 年轻人和女性受影响的比例尤其大。这凸显了针对不同年龄和性别的康复及支持项目的必要性。然而,该研究受到患者记录和联系信息不完整的限制,导致大量最初在急诊科就诊的患者被排除在外。最终,本研究强调了强有力的公共卫生准备和针对未来大规模灾难的专门护理途径的关键作用。将对这些幸存者进行进一步评估,包括神经生物标志物评估。