Templeton Da'Shay, Korchagin Ruslan, Valla Bree, Ford Jesse R
Educational Leadership, California Lutheran University, Thousand Oaks, CA 61360, USA.
Teacher Education and Higher Education, University of North Carolina at Greensboro, Greensboro, NC 27412, USA.
Children (Basel). 2025 May 26;12(6):684. doi: 10.3390/children12060684.
Through the lens of childhood trauma theory, a qualitative phenomenological study was conducted using purposive and snowball sampling methods to gain a deeper understanding of the experiences of former students with corporal punishment and how those experiences have shaped their academic and psychological outcomes. Interviews were conducted via Zoom with 19 men and women of different ages and races who attended schools in Mississippi. The study revealed that parents and school personnel collaborated to punish the student corporally both on campus and at home. Related, beaten students did not share their punishment with their parents/caregivers, and if their families did find out, they received another beating at home. There was a general lack of consistency in how and who administered corporal punishment. In addition to the well-documented ways that corporal punishment is administered in school, we also found that students were made to hold painful positions or perform painful tasks. There were also peer effects of trauma, with students experiencing fear or anger following a friend or classmate being beaten in front of them. Race was an influence if the abused students felt that their punishment was racist, with Black American participants feeling there were racial undertones regardless of the perpetrator's race. The study's findings align with those of previously conducted research, but also extend them and can be used to create policy to allow schools to address trauma and create instructional practices that eliminate the fear and racial disparities that have been proven to exist in schools with corporal punishment.
通过童年创伤理论的视角,采用目的抽样和滚雪球抽样方法进行了一项质性现象学研究,以更深入地了解曾遭受体罚的学生的经历,以及这些经历如何塑造了他们的学业和心理状况。通过Zoom对19名不同年龄和种族、曾在密西西比州上学的男女进行了访谈。研究表明,家长和学校工作人员合作,在校园和家中对学生进行体罚。此外,挨打的学生没有将他们受罚的事情告知父母/照顾者,如果家人发现了,他们会在家中再次遭到殴打。在体罚的方式和实施者方面普遍缺乏一致性。除了学校中记录在案的体罚方式外,我们还发现学生会被迫保持痛苦的姿势或执行痛苦的任务。此外,还存在创伤的同伴效应,学生在看到朋友或同学在他们面前被殴打后会感到恐惧或愤怒。如果受虐待的学生觉得他们受到的惩罚带有种族歧视,那么种族就是一个影响因素,美国黑人参与者认为无论施暴者的种族如何,都存在种族暗示。该研究的结果与之前的研究结果一致,但也有所扩展,可用于制定政策,使学校能够应对创伤,并创建教学实践,消除在存在体罚的学校中已被证明存在的恐惧和种族差异。