Chen Alexander Lishuen, Han Jun Hee, Golomb Beatrice Alexandra
University of Southern California.
University of California, San Diego.
Ann Case Rep. 2024;9(6). doi: 10.29011/2574-7754.102100. Epub 2024 Dec 4.
Mixed toxic chemical exposures are a common problem, but challenging because different chemical mixtures for each may forestall progress of relevant science. Here, we evaluate a woman exposed to multiple toxic chemicals following the February 2023 East Palestine, Ohio train derailment and toxicant release/burn, to evaluate for concordance of ensuing health problems with diagnostic criteria for Gulf War illness (GWI) - i.e. for chronic multisymptom illness following a wholly distinct mixed toxic exposure. This woman in her 30s fully met criteria for all six "Kansas criteria" symptom domains required for diagnosing mixed toxicant illness in Gulf War veterans: fatigue/sleep, neurological/cognitive/mood, pain, respiratory, gastrointestinal, and dermatologic. (Kansas symptom criteria require qualifying symptoms, of at least moderate severity and/or multiple, in at least three domains; she met criteria for all six.) She additionally had a highly distinctive problem - new post-derailment breakage and loss of teeth (culminating in removal of all teeth within the year) that was previously reported by a number of Gulf War veterans. We propose that since most chemicals' toxicity includes mitochondrial mechanisms (severity of which relates to GWI severity), this toxic mechanism may add/synergize across chemicals for many chemical mixes, producing a shared chronic health profile. Conformity of persistent health problems in this woman to the signature illness affecting Gulf War veterans suggests that knowledge from one mixed chemical exposure may be ported to others, allowing science to advance - and enabling prophylaxis and treatment measures to be developed.
混合有毒化学物质暴露是一个常见问题,但具有挑战性,因为每种不同的化学混合物可能会阻碍相关科学的进展。在这里,我们评估了一名在2023年2月俄亥俄州东巴勒斯坦火车脱轨及有毒物质释放/燃烧事件后接触多种有毒化学物质的女性,以评估随后出现的健康问题与海湾战争疾病(GWI)诊断标准的一致性——即针对完全不同的混合有毒物质暴露后的慢性多症状疾病。这名30多岁的女性完全符合海湾战争退伍军人诊断混合有毒物质疾病所需的所有六个“堪萨斯标准”症状领域:疲劳/睡眠、神经/认知/情绪、疼痛、呼吸、胃肠道和皮肤。(堪萨斯症状标准要求在至少三个领域出现至少中度严重程度和/或多种的符合条件的症状;她符合所有六个领域的标准。)她还出现了一个非常独特的问题——脱轨后新出现的牙齿破损和脱落(最终在一年内拔除了所有牙齿),此前有许多海湾战争退伍军人也报告过这种情况。我们提出,由于大多数化学物质的毒性都包括线粒体机制(其严重程度与海湾战争疾病的严重程度相关),这种毒性机制可能会在许多化学混合物中的化学物质之间相加/协同作用,产生共同的慢性健康状况。这名女性持续存在的健康问题与影响海湾战争退伍军人的标志性疾病相符,这表明从一种混合化学物质暴露中获得的知识可能适用于其他情况,从而推动科学进步——并使预防和治疗措施得以制定。