Grover Elise N, Hill Andrew C, Kasarskis Irina M, Wu Emma J, Alden Nisha B, Cronquist Alicia B, Weisbeck Kirsten, Herlihy Rachel, Carlton Elizabeth J
Department of Environmental & Occupational Health, Colorado School of Public Health, University of Colorado Anschutz, 13001 E. 17th Pl., B1119, Aurora, CO, 80045, USA.
Center for Innovative Design & Analysis, Colorado School of Public Health, University of Colorado Anschutz, Aurora, CO, USA.
Sci Rep. 2025 Jul 1;15(1):21614. doi: 10.1038/s41598-025-04192-0.
Questions remain about how best to focus surveillance efforts for COVID-19 and other emerging respiratory diseases. We used an archive of COVID-19 data in Colorado from October 2020 to March 2024 to reconstruct seven real-time surveillance indicators. We assessed how well the indicators predicted 7-day average COVID-19 hospital admissions, a key indicator of outbreak severity, using machine learning and regression models, and used cross-correlation analysis to identify leading indicators. We found that hospital-based surveillance metrics, including real-time hospital census data and emergency-department based syndromic surveillance, were among the best predictors of COVID-19 hospital admissions during and after the public health emergency (PHE). While wastewater was a weaker individual predictor, its removal from our multi-indicator models resulted in a decrease in model performance, suggesting that wastewater provides important, unique information. Likewise, we found that test positivity, while imprecise, can serve as a leading indicator of COVID-19 hospitalizations. These findings suggest hospital-based reporting should be a surveillance priority, and that wastewater surveillance and test positivity can improve situational awareness for COVID-19 in Colorado. In contrast, case reporting was not found to be essential to real-time monitoring of COVID-19 hospitalizations in Colorado. The generalizability to other regions and respiratory illnesses warrants further investigation.
关于如何以最佳方式集中开展针对新冠病毒及其他新发呼吸道疾病的监测工作,仍存在一些问题。我们利用了2020年10月至2024年3月科罗拉多州的新冠病毒数据存档,重建了七个实时监测指标。我们使用机器学习和回归模型评估了这些指标对作为疫情严重程度关键指标的新冠病毒7天平均住院人数的预测效果,并使用互相关分析来确定领先指标。我们发现,基于医院的监测指标,包括实时医院普查数据和基于急诊科的症状监测,是公共卫生紧急事件(PHE)期间及之后新冠病毒住院人数的最佳预测指标之一。虽然废水作为单一预测指标的效果较弱,但从我们的多指标模型中去除废水指标会导致模型性能下降,这表明废水提供了重要的独特信息。同样,我们发现检测阳性率虽然不够精确,但可以作为新冠病毒住院人数的领先指标。这些发现表明,基于医院的报告应作为监测重点,废水监测和检测阳性率可提高科罗拉多州对新冠病毒的态势感知。相比之下,病例报告对科罗拉多州新冠病毒住院人数的实时监测并非至关重要。这些发现对其他地区和呼吸道疾病的可推广性有待进一步研究。