Yu Chen
College of International Education and Social Development, Zhejiang Normal University, Jinhua, 321004, China.
Sci Rep. 2025 Jul 1;15(1):21095. doi: 10.1038/s41598-025-07011-8.
Previous studies have discussed the most important factor limiting whether learners can achieve advanced language proficiency. For adults, language aptitude is one of the key factors; for children, it is primarily a matter of early and sustained language experience. However, this study shows that different early cultural backgrounds lead to various levels of linguistic aptitude when learning a foreign language in adulthood. For learners from Non-Chinese-character cultural circles (abbreviated as N4C), phonetic coding ability (PCA), one of the pure linguistic abilities, is the best predictor of Chinese listening proficiency, which can explain up to 51.8% of the difference in listening level. For learners from 4 C, both PCA and executive working memory (EWM), one of the general cognitive abilities, are the best predictors of listening proficiency. Together, they can explain about 41.5% of the difference in Chinese listening level. We speculate that in early stages of language acquisition, pure linguistic abilities are shaped easier than cognitive abilities. For adult learners, whether the native language they learned before the critical period and the foreign language they learned as adults belong to the same cultural circle may impact how well they use their pure linguistic abilities.
以往的研究探讨了限制学习者能否达到高级语言水平的最重要因素。对于成年人来说,语言天赋是关键因素之一;对于儿童来说,这主要是早期持续语言体验的问题。然而,本研究表明,不同的早期文化背景会导致成年人学习外语时语言天赋水平的差异。对于来自非汉字文化圈(简称为N4C)的学习者,语音编码能力(PCA)作为一种纯粹的语言能力,是汉语听力水平的最佳预测指标,它可以解释高达51.8%的听力水平差异。对于来自汉字文化圈(4C)的学习者,PCA和执行工作记忆(EWM)作为一种一般认知能力,都是听力水平的最佳预测指标。它们共同可以解释汉语听力水平差异的约41.5%。我们推测,在语言习得的早期阶段,纯粹的语言能力比认知能力更容易形成。对于成年学习者来说,他们在关键期之前所学的母语和成年后所学的外语是否属于同一文化圈,可能会影响他们对纯粹语言能力的运用程度。