Pereira José, Meadows Lynn M, Rhayel Ashwak, Gill Ashlinder, Kljujic Dragan, Panza Michael, Faulkner Jonathan, Cm Jeffrey Moat
Institute for Culture and Society, Faculty of Medicine, University of Navarra, Pamplona, Spain.
Division of Palliative Care, Department of Family Medicine, McMaster University, Hamilton, ON, Canada.
BMC Palliat Care. 2025 Jul 1;24(1):176. doi: 10.1186/s12904-025-01804-4.
Pallium Canada's Palliative Care Extension for Community (ECHO) Project (PC ECHO) is a five-year national initiative (launched April 2021) to support continuous professional development and to facilitate the integration of palliative care across different care settings. PC ECHO includes a superhub (Pallium Canada) and several partner hubs. The goal of this formative evaluation study is to explore the project's early spread and the experiences of hub partners and participants from April 2021 to September 2023.
A mixed-methods approach was used. Webinar and participant demographic information was collected by Pallium Canada's online learning management system and by partner hubs. Participants' experience feedback was collected through a standardized online evaluation form. Project leads at the superhub and three inaugural partners were interviewed and transcriptions subjected to a thematic analysis.
A total of 301 sessions were delivered during the study period; 155 (51%) by Pallium Canada and 146 (49%) by nine partner hubs. Of these, 125 (42%) were standalone-type sessions and 176 (58%) were community of practice (COP)- or series-type sessions. A total of 7648 individuals - representing over 17 professions - participated across the 301 sessions; the nursing professions were the largest group (36.8%). There was a total of 17,467 participations across the 301 sessions, with participants from across Canada and 31% from rural or small population centres. 5105 evaluations of sessions were received (response rate 29%). Of these, 90% stated they "Agreed" or "Strongly Agreed" that the sessions were good learning experiences, and 93% indicated that they would recommend the session to colleagues. Project strengths and facilitators included accelerating partners' palliative care mandates, increased connections to other partners and resources, flexibility with the ECHO model, and funding received.
The intended outcomes of the PC ECHO Project are materializing, including utility for participants and helping partner hubs accelerate their palliative care mandates. There is evidence of significant spread, over a relatively short period of time. Future studies should include further exploration of the respective roles and impact of different session types (standalone versus communities of practice and series) and impact at higher patient and health system levels.
加拿大姑息治疗协会的社区姑息治疗扩展(ECHO)项目(PC ECHO)是一项为期五年的全国性倡议(于2021年4月启动),旨在支持持续专业发展,并促进姑息治疗在不同护理环境中的整合。PC ECHO包括一个超级中心(加拿大姑息治疗协会)和几个合作伙伴中心。这项形成性评估研究的目的是探讨该项目从2021年4月至2023年9月的早期推广情况以及中心合作伙伴和参与者的经验。
采用了混合方法。网络研讨会和参与者人口统计信息由加拿大姑息治疗协会的在线学习管理系统以及合作伙伴中心收集。参与者的经验反馈通过标准化的在线评估表收集。对超级中心和三个创始合作伙伴的项目负责人进行了访谈,并对访谈记录进行了主题分析。
在研究期间共举办了301场会议;其中155场(51%)由加拿大姑息治疗协会举办,146场(49%)由九个合作伙伴中心举办。其中,125场(42%)是独立型会议,176场(58%)是实践社区(COP)或系列型会议。共有7648人——代表超过17个专业——参加了这301场会议;护理专业人员是最大的群体(36.8%)。这301场会议共有17467人次参与,参与者来自加拿大各地,31%来自农村或人口较少的中心。共收到5105份会议评估(回复率29%)。其中,90%的人表示“同意”或“强烈同意”这些会议是良好的学习体验,93%的人表示会向同事推荐这些会议。项目的优势和促进因素包括加速合作伙伴的姑息治疗任务、增加与其他合作伙伴和资源的联系、ECHO模式的灵活性以及获得的资金。
PC ECHO项目的预期成果正在实现,包括对参与者的实用性以及帮助合作伙伴中心加速其姑息治疗任务。有证据表明在相对较短的时间内有显著的推广。未来的研究应进一步探索不同会议类型(独立型与实践社区和系列型)各自的作用和影响,以及在更高患者和卫生系统层面的影响。