Pannett B, Coggon D, Acheson E D
Br J Ind Med. 1985 Nov;42(11):777-83. doi: 10.1136/oem.42.11.777.
The job-exposure matrix described has been developed for use in population based studies of occupational morbidity and mortality in England and Wales. The job axis of the matrix is based on the Registrar General's 1966 classification of occupations and 1968 classification of industries, and comprises 669 job categories. The exposure axis is made up of 49 chemical, physical, and biological agents, most of which are known or suspected causes of occupational disease. In the body of the matrix associations between jobs and exposures are graded to four levels. The matrix has been applied to data from a case-control study of lung cancer in which occupational histories were elicited by means of a postal questionnaire. Estimates of exposure to five known or suspected carcinogens (asbestos, chromates, cutting oils, formaldehyde, and inhaled polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons were compared with those obtained by detailed review of individual occupational histories. When the matrix was used exposures were attributed to jobs more frequently than on the basis of individual histories. Lung cancer was significantly more common among subjects classed by the matrix as having potential exposure to chromates, but neither method of assigning exposures produced statistically significant associations with asbestos or polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. Possible explanations for the failure to show a clear effect of these known carcinogens are discussed. The greater accuracy of exposures inferred directly from individual histories was reflected in steeper dose response curves for asbestos, chromates, and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. The improvement over results obtained with the matrix, however, was not great. For occupational data of the type examined in this study, direct exposure estimates offer little advantage over those provided at lower cost by a matrix.
所描述的工作暴露矩阵是为在英格兰和威尔士基于人群的职业发病率和死亡率研究中使用而开发的。该矩阵的工作轴基于总登记官1966年的职业分类和1968年的行业分类,由669个工作类别组成。暴露轴由49种化学、物理和生物制剂组成,其中大多数是已知或疑似职业病病因。在矩阵主体中,工作与暴露之间的关联分为四个等级。该矩阵已应用于一项肺癌病例对照研究的数据,该研究通过邮寄问卷获取职业史。将对五种已知或疑似致癌物(石棉、铬酸盐、切削油、甲醛和吸入的多环芳烃)的暴露估计值与通过详细审查个体职业史获得的估计值进行比较。当使用矩阵时,暴露归因于工作的频率高于基于个体职业史的情况。在矩阵分类为可能接触铬酸盐的受试者中,肺癌明显更为常见,但两种暴露分配方法均未产生与石棉或多环芳烃的统计学显著关联。讨论了未能显示这些已知致癌物明显影响的可能解释。直接从个体职业史推断出的暴露具有更高的准确性,这反映在石棉、铬酸盐和多环芳烃的剂量反应曲线更陡峭上。然而,与使用矩阵获得的结果相比,改进并不显著。对于本研究中所检查类型的职业数据,直接暴露估计与以较低成本通过矩阵提供的估计相比优势不大。