Bukuluki Paul, Ndira Simon, Aweko Juliet, Kiwummulo Angelica, Ediau Michael, Namakula Justine, Ekirapa-Kiracho Elizabeth, Waiswa Peter, Mogaka John J O, Bantebya Grace
School of Social Sciences, Makerere University, Kampala, Kampala, Uganda
Compelling Works, Kampala, Uganda.
BMJ Glob Health. 2025 Jul 16;10(Suppl 4):e017475. doi: 10.1136/bmjgh-2024-017475.
Gender is a key factor shaping societal roles and access to resources, with cultural norms often limiting women's abilities to use digital financial services. Despite the rise of digital payments, little is known about how gender relations influence their adoption and experience, especially among health workers involved in vaccination campaigns.
Between January and September 2023, we explored how gender norms and relations influence the uptake and experiences of digital payments among health workers participating in mass polio vaccination campaigns. The qualitative study involved 23 focused group discussions (FGDs; 16 in Uganda and 7 in Malawi) and 82 in-depth interviews (IDIs; 35 in Uganda and 47 in Malawi) with healthcare workers who received digital payments for implementing polio mass vaccination campaigns. IDI participants included village health teams, midwives, nurses, health facility managers, immunisation focal persons and district health officers in Uganda, and community health workers, health facility managers and mobile money operators in Malawi. FGDs were held with midwives, nurses and village health teams in Uganda and community health workers in Malawi. Data were coded using Dedoose software and thematically analysed.
Participants highlighted that digital payments were convenient since they were able to receive funds without travelling long distances or queuing at health facilities. Women reported that it gave them more time to engage in alternative activities, improve their financial autonomy and ability to participate in decision-making around use of household funds. Structural challenges leading to delayed disbursement of funds were reported to reinforce gender norms around financial dependency on men to meet operational campaign costs (eg, transport). Reported limited ownership of mobile money accounts, a prerequisite for digital payments, led to the exclusion of some women.
Our findings suggest that digital payments could help improve financial autonomy and participation in decision-making around use of household funds among women involved in immunisation campaigns. However, our findings show that digital payments are implemented in the context of prevailing harmful gender norms that, if not addressed, have the potential to compromise women's agency. This underscores the importance of integrating gender-transformative programming in planning for digital payments during vaccination campaigns.
性别是塑造社会角色和获取资源的关键因素,文化规范常常限制女性使用数字金融服务的能力。尽管数字支付兴起,但对于性别关系如何影响其采用和体验,尤其是参与疫苗接种运动的卫生工作者中的情况,人们了解甚少。
在2023年1月至9月期间,我们探讨了性别规范和关系如何影响参与大规模脊髓灰质炎疫苗接种运动的卫生工作者对数字支付的采用和体验。这项定性研究包括与因实施脊髓灰质炎大规模疫苗接种运动而接受数字支付的医护人员进行的23次焦点小组讨论(乌干达16次,马拉维7次)和82次深入访谈(乌干达35次,马拉维47次)。深入访谈的参与者包括乌干达的乡村卫生团队、助产士、护士、卫生机构管理人员、免疫重点人员和地区卫生官员,以及马拉维的社区卫生工作者、卫生机构管理人员和移动货币运营商。焦点小组讨论在乌干达与助产士、护士和乡村卫生团队以及马拉维的社区卫生工作者中进行。数据使用Dedoose软件进行编码并进行主题分析。
参与者强调数字支付很方便,因为他们无需长途跋涉或在卫生机构排队就能收到资金。女性报告称,这使她们有更多时间参与其他活动,提高了她们的财务自主权以及参与家庭资金使用决策的能力。据报告,导致资金发放延迟的结构性挑战强化了围绕在满足行动成本(如交通)方面对男性财务依赖的性别规范。据报告,作为数字支付先决条件的移动货币账户所有权有限,导致一些女性被排除在外。
我们的研究结果表明,数字支付有助于提高参与免疫运动的女性的财务自主权以及她们参与家庭资金使用决策的程度。然而,我们的研究结果表明,数字支付是在普遍存在的有害性别规范背景下实施的,如果不加以解决,这些规范有可能损害女性的能动性。这凸显了在疫苗接种运动期间数字支付规划中纳入性别变革性方案的重要性。