Gunawan Denish, Antico Lia, Nardi William, Brewer Judson
Brown University School of Public Health, Providence, RI, USA.
Department of Behavioral and Social Sciences, Brown University School of Public Health, Providence, RI, USA.
BMC Med Educ. 2025 Jul 17;25(1):1072. doi: 10.1186/s12909-025-07642-5.
BACKGROUND & AIMS: Medical students experience high rates of psychological distress, including depression, anxiety, burnout, and suicidality, due to rigorous academic demands. Mindfulness-Based Interventions (MBI) have demonstrated small-to-moderate effectiveness in reducing stress and improving well-being, yet culturally adapted and developmentally appropriate programs for Indonesian medical students remain limited. This study aims to develop and evaluate the Mindfulness Program for Pre-Clinical Medical Students in Indonesia (MPPMS-I) to determine its feasibility, acceptability, and suitability in addressing the mental health needs of pre-clinical medical students.
This study employed a convergent mixed methods approach guided by the User-Centered Design (UCD) framework which emphasized iterative development based on user feedback. First-, second-, and third-year pre-clinical medical students were recruited between May and July 2024. The study was conducted in three iterative phases, each involving different participant groups to refine MPPMS-I: Phase 1 assessed initial impressions and interest, Phase 2 evaluated program relevance and clarity, and Phase 3 gathered detailed feedback on individual sessions to finalize the module. Quantitative analysis examined participant characteristics, interest levels, program relevance, applicability of learned concepts, and instructional clarity. Qualitative analysis were analyzed using framework analysis to explore themes such as participants' first impressions, key lessons learned, beneficial aspects, daily integration of mindfulness practices, and barriers and facilitators to participation. Dual coding was used to enhance trustworthiness.
Findings revealed three key insights: (1) a moderate and rising level of interest (mean range: 5.75 to 6.6), supported by qualitative feedback indicating increased engagement following iterative refinement; (2) The program was perceived as highly relevant to students' academic and personal challenges, particularly around stress, perfectionism, and communication; and (3) Participants reported a high likelihood of applying what they learned, such as mindfulness practices like S.T.O.P. meditation and journaling, into their daily routines.in their daily lives. Themes of relevance, practical benefit, and cultural fit emerged prominently in qualitative feedback.
This study suggests that MPPMS-I is a feasible, culturally appropriate, and suitable intervention for pre-clinical medical students in Indonesia. Participants found it helpful for stress management, personal growth, and improving communication. As the program remains in an early evaluative phase, future research should include a longitudinal pilot study involving clinical students and assess long-term outcomes. Integrating MPPMS-I into medical curricula could offer a sustainable and context-sensitive approach to enhancing student well-being and resilience.
Not applicable.
由于学业要求严格,医学生经历心理困扰的比例很高,包括抑郁、焦虑、职业倦怠和自杀倾向。基于正念的干预措施(MBI)在减轻压力和改善幸福感方面已显示出一定效果,但针对印度尼西亚医学生的文化适应且适合其发展阶段的项目仍然有限。本研究旨在开发和评估印度尼西亚临床前医学生正念项目(MPPMS - I),以确定其在满足临床前医学生心理健康需求方面的可行性、可接受性和适用性。
本研究采用以用户为中心的设计(UCD)框架指导的收敛性混合方法,强调根据用户反馈进行迭代开发。在2024年5月至7月期间招募了临床前医学生的一年级、二年级和三年级学生。该研究分三个迭代阶段进行,每个阶段涉及不同的参与者群体以完善MPPMS - I:第1阶段评估初始印象和兴趣,第2阶段评估项目相关性和清晰度,第3阶段收集关于各个课程的详细反馈以确定模块。定量分析考察参与者特征、兴趣水平、项目相关性、所学概念的适用性以及教学清晰度。定性分析采用框架分析来探索诸如参与者的第一印象、关键收获、有益方面、正念练习的日常融入以及参与的障碍和促进因素等主题。采用双重编码以提高可信度。
研究结果揭示了三个关键见解:(1)兴趣水平适中且呈上升趋势(平均范围:5.75至6.6),定性反馈表明经过迭代完善后参与度有所提高;(2)该项目被认为与学生的学业和个人挑战高度相关,特别是在压力、完美主义和沟通方面;(3)参与者报告称很有可能将所学内容,如“停下、呼吸、观察、觉察”(S.T.O.P.)冥想和写日记等正念练习应用到日常生活中。相关性、实际益处和文化契合等主题在定性反馈中显著出现。
本研究表明MPPMS - I对印度尼西亚临床前医学生是一种可行、文化上合适且适用的干预措施。参与者发现它有助于压力管理、个人成长和改善沟通能力。由于该项目仍处于早期评估阶段,未来研究应包括涉及临床学生的纵向试点研究并评估长期结果。将MPPMS - I纳入医学课程可以提供一种可持续且符合实际情况的方法来提高学生的幸福感和适应能力。
不适用。