Lemaire Koen K, Kistemaker Dinant A, Jaspers Richard T, van der Laarse Willem J, van Soest A J 'Knoek'
Department of Human Movement Sciences, VU University Amsterdam, Van Der Boechorststraat 9, 1081 Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Laboratory for Myology, Department of Human Movement Sciences, VU University Amsterdam, Van Der Boechorststraat 9, 1081 Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
J Exp Biol. 2025 Aug 1;228(15). doi: 10.1242/jeb.249242.
The aim of this study was to advance muscle models that unify mechanical behaviour and metabolic energy expenditure. To that end, we compared predictions of force and metabolic energy expenditure of a Huxley-type muscle-tendon complex (MTC) model with previously obtained experimental data. In our published model, we extended the classic Huxley formulation by incorporating force-length dependency, series elasticity and activation dynamics. Metabolic energy expenditure was modelled as the weighted sum of cross-bridge cycling and calcium pumping costs. In the associated experiment, fibre bundles from nine mouse soleus muscles underwent sinusoidal contractions, while oxygen consumption and tendon force were measured. The bundles were stimulated during both shortening and lengthening, and measurements were taken before and after adding blebbistatin, which blocks cross-bridge cycling but leaves calcium handling unaffected. This enabled separate estimation of metabolic energy costs for each process. In the present study, we modelled these previously published data. Parameters governing model mechanical behaviour were calibrated using trials without oxygen measurements. We used these parameters in simulations of the oxygen measurement trials, and metabolic parameters were optimized to best match average metabolic power. We found that simulated and measured forces corresponded well (root-mean-square error, RMSE <10% of maximum force). Metabolic energy predictions showed higher error (mean RMSE 20.3%, s.d. 12.6% of measured value), with large inter-animal variability. In four animals, where repeated measures were consistent and data followed expected trends, predictions of metabolic energy expenditure were accurate (RMSE <15%). In the remaining five, greater variability or inconsistent data patterns led to poorer fits. Despite this, given the within-animal variability in oxygen measurements, the metabolic predictions are promising. Combined with previous findings, these results support the potential of Huxley-type models in predictive simulations of human metabolic energy expenditure.
本研究的目的是改进肌肉模型,使其能够统一力学行为和代谢能量消耗。为此,我们将赫胥黎型肌肉-肌腱复合体(MTC)模型的力和代谢能量消耗预测与先前获得的实验数据进行了比较。在我们已发表的模型中,我们通过纳入力-长度依赖性、串联弹性和激活动力学扩展了经典的赫胥黎公式。代谢能量消耗被建模为横桥循环和钙泵成本的加权和。在相关实验中,对来自九只小鼠比目鱼肌的纤维束进行正弦收缩,同时测量氧气消耗和肌腱力。在缩短和伸长过程中均对纤维束进行刺激,并在添加blebbistatin前后进行测量,blebbistatin可阻断横桥循环,但不影响钙处理。这使得能够分别估计每个过程的代谢能量成本。在本研究中,我们对这些先前发表的数据进行了建模。使用无氧测量的试验校准控制模型力学行为的参数。我们在氧气测量试验的模拟中使用这些参数,并优化代谢参数以使其与平均代谢功率最佳匹配。我们发现模拟力和测量力吻合良好(均方根误差,RMSE<最大力的10%)。代谢能量预测显示出更高的误差(平均RMSE为20.3%,标准差为测量值的12.6%),动物个体间差异较大。在四只动物中,重复测量结果一致且数据符合预期趋势,代谢能量消耗的预测较为准确(RMSE<15%)。在其余五只动物中,更大的变异性或不一致的数据模式导致拟合效果较差。尽管如此,考虑到动物个体间氧气测量的变异性,代谢预测仍很有前景。结合先前的研究结果,这些结果支持了赫胥黎型模型在预测人类代谢能量消耗模拟中的潜力。