Zaidi Syed Mohammad Asad, Creswell Jacob, Khowaja Saira, Khan Aamir, Copas Andrew, Esmail Hanif
WHO Centre for Tuberculosis Research and Innovation, Institute for Global Health, University College London, London, UK
Community Health Solutions, Karachi, Pakistan.
BMJ Glob Health. 2025 Jul 22;10(7):e019133. doi: 10.1136/bmjgh-2025-019133.
Recent evidence suggests that community-wide active case finding (ACF) can reduce tuberculosis (TB) incidence and prevalence. Mass-screening at the community level, supported by mobile digital chest X-ray units, is now being scaled up by programmes across high burden countries. However, there is limited evidence of case-detection yields from programmes conducting ACF at scale in low-resource settings. We retrospectively analysed aggregate data from mobile X-ray screening events (called 'camps') in Pakistan from Q3 2017 to Q2 2021. A total of 11 327 camps were conducted that screened 1 214 289 individuals and detected 7625 cases of All-Forms TB (AF-TB), among whom 3500 (45.9%) were bacteriologically confirmed (B+) and the remaining were treated empirically. The yield for B+ and AF-TB per 100 000 population screened nationally was 289 (95% CI: 279 to 298) and 631 (95% CI: 617 to 646), respectively. Yield of TB detected from screening was highly variable between regions of Pakistan, ranging from 70 to 678 per 100 000 B+ and 76 to 1136 per 100 000 for AF-TB. Our findings have two major lessons for TB programmes. First, there was significant geographical variation in yields of both B+ and AF-TB, supporting targeting of interventions in areas of high prevalence to maximise the intervention's effectiveness. Second, more than half of TB cases were treated empirically, and approaches to improve sample collection, linkage to diagnostics, non-sputum based tests and standardisation of treatment for bacteriologically unconfirmed TB need to be concurrently prioritised by programmes considering scale-up of mobile X-ray-based ACF.
近期证据表明,全社区主动病例发现(ACF)可降低结核病(TB)的发病率和患病率。在移动数字胸部X光设备的支持下,社区层面的大规模筛查目前正在高负担国家的各项计划中扩大规模。然而,在资源匮乏地区大规模开展ACF的计划中,病例检出率的证据有限。我们回顾性分析了2017年第三季度至2021年第二季度巴基斯坦移动X光筛查活动(称为“营地”)的汇总数据。共开展了11327次营地筛查,筛查了1214289人,检测出7625例所有类型结核病(AF-TB),其中3500例(45.9%)经细菌学确诊(B+),其余为经验性治疗。全国每10万人口筛查的B+和AF-TB检出率分别为289(95%CI:279至298)和631(95%CI:617至646)。巴基斯坦各地区筛查出的结核病检出率差异很大,每10万人口中B+的检出率为70至678,AF-TB的检出率为76至1136。我们的研究结果为结核病防治计划提供了两个主要经验教训。第一,B+和AF-TB的检出率在地理上存在显著差异,这支持在高流行地区开展干预措施,以最大限度地提高干预效果。第二,超过一半的结核病病例是经验性治疗,对于考虑扩大基于移动X光的ACF规模的计划而言,需要同时优先采取措施改善样本采集、与诊断的衔接、非痰检以及细菌学未确诊结核病的标准化治疗。