Mitchell Ashley, Simwinga Luseshelo, Blair Alden, Rouse Miranda, Baltzell Kimberly, Malirakwenda Richard, Jere Joyce, Mwanza Oveka
Institute for Global Health Sciences, University of California, San Francisco, San Francisco, California, United States of America.
Global Action in Nursing (GAIN), University of California, San Francisco, San Francisco, California, United States of America.
PLOS Glob Public Health. 2025 Jul 24;5(7):e0004939. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0004939. eCollection 2025.
Despite high rates of facility delivery and skilled attendance at birth in Malawi, maternal mortality remains high underscoring the need to improve quality of care. With most deaths occurring at secondary and tertiary levels of care, our midwifery-led team aimed to understand the characteristics of pre-referral care driving poor maternal outcomes. We leveraged a convergent, parallel mixed methods approach to characterize obstetric care and outcomes across the referral care continuum and explore facilitators and barriers to the referral process between March 2019 and March 2020. Complex obstetric patient charts from seven Blantyre District primary health centers referred to the only local tertiary hospital were extracted and analyzed for associations between individual- and facility-level characteristics and referral care and outcomes. Transcripts from three focus group discussions and 18 in-depth interviews with clinical providers and referred mothers were analyzed using qualitative inference. Among 398 birthing women, 54% were between 18 and 24 years-old and 32% were referred from a facility more than 10km from the Hospital. Compared to survivors, mothers who died (n = 10) were significantly more likely to have been referred from a facility >10 km away, to have arrived in critical condition, and 100% experienced complications during their stay ranging from postpartum hemorrhage to cardiac arrest. Three primary themes emerged as barriers to quality pre-referral care in the district: systemic and structural challenges, inconsistent inter- and intra-facility communication, and community and provider influences on maternal expectations and beliefs. Triangulation of these findings suggests that strengthening referral infrastructure, bolstering communication and documentation, and reducing total referral time are key to improving care quality and outcomes for complex obstetric cases. Additionally, providers across the care continuum need additional training and support to ensure timely interventions and comprehensive, continuous referral care.
尽管马拉维的机构分娩率和熟练接生率很高,但孕产妇死亡率仍然居高不下,这凸显了提高护理质量的必要性。由于大多数死亡发生在二级和三级护理层面,我们以助产士为主导的团队旨在了解导致孕产妇不良结局的转诊前护理特征。我们采用了一种收敛性、平行混合方法,以描述转诊护理连续过程中的产科护理和结局,并在2019年3月至2020年3月期间探索转诊过程的促进因素和障碍。从七个布兰太尔区初级卫生中心转诊到当地唯一一家三级医院的复杂产科患者病历被提取出来,分析个体和机构层面特征与转诊护理及结局之间的关联。使用定性推理分析了来自三次焦点小组讨论以及对临床提供者和转诊母亲进行的18次深入访谈的文字记录。在398名分娩妇女中,54%的年龄在18至24岁之间,32%是从距离医院10公里以上的机构转诊而来。与幸存者相比,死亡的母亲(n = 10)更有可能是从距离超过10公里的机构转诊而来,到达时病情危急,并且100%在住院期间经历了从产后出血到心脏骤停等并发症。出现了三个主要主题,成为该地区高质量转诊前护理的障碍:系统和结构挑战、机构间和机构内沟通不一致,以及社区和提供者对孕产妇期望和信念的影响。这些研究结果的三角验证表明,加强转诊基础设施、加强沟通和记录以及减少总转诊时间是改善复杂产科病例护理质量和结局的关键。此外,整个护理连续过程中的提供者需要额外的培训和支持,以确保及时干预和全面、持续的转诊护理。