Dimitropoulos Gina, Nicula Maria, Krishnapillai Andrea, Austin Amelia, Singh Manya, Lee Jayden, Webb Cheryl, Scott Sela, de Almeida Ana Cláudia Vieira, Bergmann Clara, Vander Steen Heidi, Kimber Melissa, Mushquash Christopher, Norman Lia, Sauerwein Jessica, Keshen Aaron, Boachie Ahmed, Toulany Alène, Levinson Andrea, Federici Anita, Allemang Brooke, Ford Catherine, Katzman Debra K, Tam Emily, McVey Gail, Steiger Howard, Scarborough Jennifer, Coelho Jennifer S, Thannhauser Jennifer, Geller Josie, Darnay Karleigh, Henderson Jo, Bright Katherine, Soper Katie, Isserlin Leanna, Booij Linda, Brouwers Melissa, Laliberté Michele, Jericho Monique, Obeid Nicole, Smith Sarah, Grewal Seena, MacEachern Shauna, Findlay Sheri, Preskow Wendy, Spettigue Wendy, Maharaj Aryel, Wozney Lori, Iyer Srividya, Norris Mark, Vallianatos Helen, Jones Shaleen, Lacroix Emilie, Ferrari Manuela, Steinegger Cathleen, Loewen Techiya, Gusella Joanne, LeClerc Anick, Johnson Natasha, Phillips Suzanne, Patton Megan, Punjwani Zoya, Greer Katelyn, Bhatnagar Neera, Couturier Jennifer
Faculty of Social Work, University of Calgary, Calgary, AB, Canada.
Department of Psychiatry, Mathison Centre for Mental Health Research and Education, University of Calgary, Calgary, AB, Canada.
J Eat Disord. 2025 Jul 28;13(1):158. doi: 10.1186/s40337-025-01343-6.
Eating disorders (EDs) are severe mental illnesses with high rates of mortality, morbidity, and reduced quality of life. Their onset occurs during adolescence and early adulthood, coinciding with the critical transition from pediatric to adult care. To address the lack of guidelines to support ED transitions in Canada, this study developed evidence-based guideline recommendations.
Scoping review methodology was employed using comprehensive searches across seven databases, supplemented by forward and backward citation chaining to identify records on youth and young adults (YYAs) (16-25 years) with EDs and/or mental health conditions transitioning from pediatric to adult care. The Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation approach was used to evaluate the quality of the evidence for applicable studies. Using a modified Delphi method, the evidence was reviewed by a guideline development panel and consensus was achieved in a single round of voting.
After de-duplication, 14,350 records from all sources were screened, with 1817 studies undergoing full-text review. A total of 419 studies were included. Of these, 199 were primary research studies which fell under one or more of the following categories: descriptive (n = 86), qualitative (n = 75), predictors (n = 48), transition interventions (n = 21), measurement tools (n = 8), and key outcomes (n = 3). The certainty of the evidence for specific interventions and tools was generally low.
The panel issued strong recommendations for integrated, collaborative transition approaches involving YYAs, families, and providers, and for the use of the Transition Readiness Assessment Questionnaire (TRAQ) to support transition planning. Additional recommendations are included, with an emphasis on future research focused on long-term outcomes such as care continuity and treatment retention.
This research addressed the absence of a cohesive approach to transitions for YYAs experiencing EDs and/or mental health conditions, highlighting evidence variability and the need for a unified approach. These guidelines propose actionable steps for improving care transitions for YYAs with EDs and/or mental health conditions by promoting collaborative care models, prioritizing outcome-focused research, and using measurement tools.
饮食失调是严重的精神疾病,死亡率、发病率高,生活质量下降。其发病于青春期和成年早期,恰逢从儿科护理向成人护理的关键过渡阶段。为解决加拿大缺乏支持饮食失调患者过渡护理的指南这一问题,本研究制定了基于证据的指南建议。
采用范围综述方法,全面检索七个数据库,并辅以向前和向后的引文链,以识别患有饮食失调和/或心理健康状况的青少年和青年(16 - 25岁)从儿科护理过渡到成人护理的相关记录。使用推荐分级评估、制定和评价方法来评估适用研究的证据质量。通过改良的德尔菲法,由指南制定小组对证据进行审查,并在一轮投票中达成共识。
去重后,对来自所有来源的14350条记录进行了筛选,1817项研究进行了全文审查。共纳入419项研究。其中,199项为原发性研究,属于以下一个或多个类别:描述性研究(n = 86)、定性研究(n = 75)、预测因素研究(n = 48)、过渡干预研究(n = 21)、测量工具研究(n = 8)和关键结局研究(n = 3)。特定干预措施和工具的证据确定性普遍较低。
该小组强烈建议采用涉及青少年和青年、家庭及医疗服务提供者的综合协作过渡方法,并使用过渡准备评估问卷(TRAQ)来支持过渡计划。还包括其他建议,重点是未来针对长期结局(如护理连续性和治疗持续性)的研究。
本研究解决了对患有饮食失调和/或心理健康状况的青少年和青年缺乏连贯过渡方法的问题,突出了证据的可变性以及统一方法的必要性。这些指南提出了可采取的措施,通过促进协作护理模式、优先开展以结局为重点的研究以及使用测量工具,改善患有饮食失调和/或心理健康状况的青少年和青年的护理过渡。