Li Mohan, Jiang Shan, Li Jiaojiao, Chen Xiling, Ma Lan, Guo Qihao, Wang Yuehui, Luo Lan, An Liping, Wu Yonghua, Huang Wei, Yuan Ludan, Wang Lin, Ding Xiping, Zhao Xujing, Zhang Zhongyuan, Zhang Hongyu, Wu Yin, Yang Rong, Liu Yang, Cao Jian, Liu Xiaohong
Department of Geriatrics at Peking Union Medical College, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences, Peking Union Medical College Hospital, No. 1 Shuaifuyuan, Dongcheng District, Beijing, 100730, China.
Department of Geriatrics, The Second Affiliated Hospital of Zhengzhou University, No.2 Jingba Road, Jinshui District, Zhengzhou City, Henan Province, 450014, China.
BMC Geriatr. 2025 Jul 31;25(1):571. doi: 10.1186/s12877-025-06175-2.
Dysphagia and malnutrition increase with age and are correlated with adverse clinical outcomes. Researchers have not fully studied the safety and effectiveness between oral nutrition pathway and tube feeding in dysphagic and malnourished elderly individuals.
Elderly individuals > 65 years old with nutrition risk admitted to the department of geriatrics from 58 third-grade hospitals between September 2020 and December 2022 were recruited. The analysis was conducted in patients with moderate dysphagia. Baseline characteristics, including demography, nutrition, swallowing function and body function, were collected per inclusion. Nutritional suggestions were given by geriatricians and nutritionists. Nutritional therapy pathways were recorded, and the body and functional measurements were repeated at discharge and the 90-day follow-up. Adverse outcomes, including new-onset pneumonia, falls, unplanned readmission and all-cause death were recorded.
A total of 1027 hospitalized elderly individuals were included, with 168 (16.4%) having moderate dysphagia. Among the participants receiving oral nutrition or tube feeding, 91 (81.3%) and 45 (80.4%) gained sufficient calories after nutritional intervention and were included in the analysis. The median age was 89 (IQR: 82-92) years, 43 (31.6%) were female, and 128 (94.1%) were malnourished. Ninety-one (66.9%) patients were treated with oral nutrition (oral diet or oral nutritional supplements), and 45 (33.1%) were treated with tube feeding. Among the oral nutrition patients, 11 (12.1%), 3 (3.3%), 14 (16.7%) and 2 (2.6%) had new-onset pneumonia, all-cause death, readmission and falls, respectively. The corresponding events in the tube-feeding group were 5 (11.1%), 1 (2.2%), 7 (16.7%) and 1 (2.5%). No statistically significant difference was observed between nutrition treatment pathways. BMI, grip strength and calf circumference increased similarly between the oral nutrition and tube-feeding groups, whereas the percentage of improved MNA-SF status was greater in the oral nutrition group than in the tube-feeding group (53% vs. 26%, p = 0.004).
Among moderately dysphagic geriatric inpatients with malnutrition or nutritional risk, oral nutritional may demonstrate comparable safety to tube feeding regarding new-onset pneumonia, all-cause death, readmissions, and falls during short term follow-up. Oral nutrition may also demonstrate comparable effectiveness in terms of energy supply and improving function, and oral nutrition may be more effective in improving nutritional status.
ClinicalTrials.gov: NCT04751032.
吞咽困难和营养不良随着年龄增长而增加,并且与不良临床结局相关。研究人员尚未充分研究吞咽困难和营养不良的老年个体中口服营养途径与管饲之间的安全性和有效性。
招募2020年9月至2022年12月期间来自58家三级医院老年医学科的65岁以上有营养风险的老年人。对中度吞咽困难患者进行分析。纳入时收集基线特征,包括人口统计学、营养、吞咽功能和身体功能。由老年医学专家和营养师给出营养建议。记录营养治疗途径,并在出院时和90天随访时重复进行身体和功能测量。记录不良结局,包括新发肺炎、跌倒、非计划再入院和全因死亡。
共纳入1027名住院老年人,其中168名(16.4%)有中度吞咽困难。在接受口服营养或管饲的参与者中,91名(81.3%)和45名(80.4%)在营养干预后获得了足够的热量并纳入分析。中位年龄为89岁(四分位间距:82 - 92岁),43名(31.6%)为女性,128名(94.1%)营养不良。91名(66.9%)患者接受口服营养治疗(口服饮食或口服营养补充剂),45名(33.1%)接受管饲治疗。在口服营养患者中,分别有11名(12.1%)、3名(3.3%)、14名(16.7%)和2名(2.6%)发生新发肺炎、全因死亡、再入院和跌倒。管饲组的相应事件分别为5名(11.1%)、1名(2.2%)、7名(16.7%)和1名(2.5%)。营养治疗途径之间未观察到统计学显著差异。口服营养组和管饲组的体重指数、握力和小腿围度增加情况相似,而口服营养组中MNA - SF状态改善的百分比高于管饲组(53%对26%,p = 0.004)。
在中度吞咽困难的营养不良或有营养风险的老年住院患者中,在短期随访期间,口服营养在新发肺炎、全因死亡、再入院和跌倒方面可能显示出与管饲相当的安全性。口服营养在能量供应和改善功能方面也可能显示出相当的有效性,并且口服营养在改善营养状况方面可能更有效。
ClinicalTrials.gov:NCT04751032。