Du Jiaolan, Ye Feng, Zhang Min, Zeng Jinping, Duan Ting, Song Qin, Yang Jun, Wu Yinyin
Department of Epidemiology and Health Statistics, School of Public Health, Hangzhou Normal University, Hangzhou, China.
School of Pharmacy, Hangzhou Normal University, Hangzhou, China.
Front Public Health. 2025 Jul 17;13:1588303. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2025.1588303. eCollection 2025.
Frailty progression may lead to adverse clinical events. Timely intervention of individual with heterogeneous frailty trajectories are important to prevent or reverse frailty progression.
This study aimed to develop nomograms to predict heterogeneous frailty progression, and validate their predictive performance.
4,406 participants (2,268 in the development cohort and 2,138 in the validation cohort) were included in this study. Latent class trajectory model (LCTM) was used to identify the heterogeneous frailty trajectories. Lasso regression analysis was employed to screen predictive factors. The nomogram models were subsequently developed using multivariable logistic regression analysis. Model performance was internally validated with bootstrap resampling and externally validated using independent data. The discrimination and calibration were assessed by C-index and calibration curve, respectively.
Two prediction nomograms were developed and validated to estimate the risk of future frailty progression based on three identified frailty trajectories. Eleven predictors were determined in the medium-stable nomogram. The internal and external validation C-indices were 0.86 and 0.77; the calibration curves demonstrated that the predicted probabilities fit well with the actual observation. Six predictors were determined in the low-rapid nomogram. The internal and external validation C-indices were 0.74 and 0.62, respectively, and calibration curves indicated good calibration.
Frailty trajectories provide more predictive value than frailty states. This study developed nomogram models to predict frailty progression, identifying key predictors such as gender, cognitive impairment, lifestyle factors, and early life experiences, with promising validation results.
The nomograms demonstrated favorable performance and may help making public health strategies for more precise frailty management.
衰弱进展可能导致不良临床事件。及时干预具有异质性衰弱轨迹的个体对于预防或逆转衰弱进展至关重要。
本研究旨在开发列线图以预测异质性衰弱进展,并验证其预测性能。
本研究纳入了4406名参与者(开发队列2268名,验证队列2138名)。使用潜在类别轨迹模型(LCTM)识别异质性衰弱轨迹。采用套索回归分析筛选预测因素。随后使用多变量逻辑回归分析开发列线图模型。模型性能通过自助重采样进行内部验证,并使用独立数据进行外部验证。分别通过C指数和校准曲线评估辨别力和校准情况。
基于三条已识别的衰弱轨迹,开发并验证了两个预测列线图,以估计未来衰弱进展的风险。在中稳定列线图中确定了11个预测因素。内部和外部验证的C指数分别为0.86和0.77;校准曲线表明预测概率与实际观察结果拟合良好。在低快速列线图中确定了6个预测因素。内部和外部验证的C指数分别为0.74和0.62,校准曲线显示校准良好。
衰弱轨迹比衰弱状态具有更高的预测价值。本研究开发了列线图模型来预测衰弱进展,识别了诸如性别、认知障碍、生活方式因素和早期生活经历等关键预测因素,验证结果良好。
列线图表现良好,可能有助于制定公共卫生策略以更精确地管理衰弱。