Bhattacharya Shamayeta, Ghosh Debarchana
Department of Community Engagement, Point Park University, Pittsburgh, USA.
Department of Geography, University of Connecticut, Storrs, USA.
Int J Transgend Health. 2024 Jan 25;26(3):571-591. doi: 10.1080/26895269.2023.2301306. eCollection 2025.
Gender-diverse individuals encounter a greater number of barriers to healthcare access, stemming from stigma, insufficient awareness, unavailability of gender-affirming healthcare, limited social support, and minimal legal protections. These barriers have a differential impact on healthcare access for the hijra, kothi, or transgender (HKT) communities in India.
We, first, developed a multidimensional access to healthcare index (MAHI) to assess disparities in access among HKT individuals; and second, identified the social (SDoH) and structural (STDoH) determinants of health that are associated with their access.
Data on a variety of healthcare access questions were collected from a representative sample of HKT individuals ( = 98). We conducted a Principal Component Analysis (PCA) to build the multidimensional index and calculate a composite score of access. An ANOVA test to identify the determinants associated with their access, and geospatial analysis to explore the spatial variability of access were conducted.
PCA identified six dimensions-affordability, acceptance, accommodation, accessibility, accompaniment, and awareness-that comprehensively described MAHI. The mean score of MAHI for participants was 42.0 (minimum = 19.6; maximum = 74.7) on a scale from 0 to 100 (where 0 represented best and 100 represented worst healthcare access). The mean MAHI scores varied by two SDoH, gender identity and educational qualifications ( < 0.001), where hijras with no education had the worst access. Geospatial analysis indicated that disparities in access were linked to participant's neighborhood characteristics and identified clusters of participants with high and low access in the southeast and northwest regions of the city respectively.
The MAHI recommends six strategies for improving access and mitigating health disparities among the hijra, kothi, and transgender individuals in India. It underscores the significance of recognizing the diverse nature of gender identities in health research.
性别多元化个体在获得医疗保健方面面临更多障碍,这些障碍源于耻辱感、认识不足、缺乏性别肯定性医疗保健、社会支持有限以及法律保护极少。这些障碍对印度的海吉拉、科蒂或跨性别者(HKT)群体获得医疗保健产生了不同的影响。
第一,我们开发了一个多维医疗保健获取指数(MAHI),以评估HKT个体在获取医疗保健方面的差异;第二,确定与其获取医疗保健相关的社会健康决定因素(SDoH)和结构健康决定因素(STDoH)。
从HKT个体的代表性样本(n = 98)中收集了各种医疗保健获取问题的数据。我们进行了主成分分析(PCA)以构建多维指数并计算获取的综合得分。进行了方差分析以确定与其获取相关的决定因素,并进行了地理空间分析以探索获取的空间变异性。
主成分分析确定了六个维度——可承受性、接受度、适应性、可及性、陪伴和认知——全面描述了MAHI。参与者的MAHI平均得分为42.0(最低 = 19.6;最高 = 74.7),范围为0至100(其中0表示最佳,100表示最差的医疗保健获取情况)。MAHI平均得分因两个社会健康决定因素而异,即性别认同和教育程度(p < 0.001),其中未受过教育的海吉拉获取情况最差。地理空间分析表明,获取方面的差异与参与者的邻里特征有关,并分别在城市的东南部和西北部地区确定了获取情况高和低的参与者集群。
MAHI推荐了六种策略,以改善印度海吉拉、科蒂和跨性别个体的医疗保健获取情况并减轻健康差异。它强调了在健康研究中认识性别认同多样性的重要性。