Lu Baobin, Yu Leyong, Yu Hairui, Rahman Abdur, Ma Chengyu, Wu Xiaojing, Li Lingyao, Sherzada Shahid, Hussain Nimra
College of Fisheries and Life Science, Shanghai Ocean University, Shanghai 201306, China.
Key Laboratory of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology in Universities of Shandong (Weifang University), Weifang Key Laboratory of Coho Salmon Culturing Facility Engineering, Institute of Modern Facility Fisheries, College of Biology and Oceanography, Weifang University, Weifang 261061, China.
Aquac Nutr. 2025 Jul 28;2025:3047597. doi: 10.1155/anu/3047597. eCollection 2025.
The aquafeed industry relies on fish meal as a major protein source, but its use raises economic and environmental concerns, prompting the search for sustainable alternatives. This study compared the apparent digestibility coefficients (ADCs) of dry matter (DM), energy, protein, phosphorus, lipids, and amino acids (AAs) for selected protein ingredients in Coho salmon. For this purpose, one reference and seven test diets corresponding to beer yeast (BY), corn gluten meal (CGM), cottonseed meal (CSM), peanut meal (PNM), rapeseed meal (RSM), soybean meal(SBM), and soy protein concentrate (SPC) were formulated with the ratio of 70:30 of the reference diet and one of the test ingredients. 1200 fish were randomly distributed into 24 glass aquaria (each with a diameter of 3.0 m and a depth of 1.5 m, water volume 8.5 m³) with three aquaria per experimental diet (total = 50 24 = 1200). The experiment lasted for 8 weeks. The results indicated that ADCs of DM ranged from 43.34% for RSM to 72.90% for SPC. Similarly, the highest ADCs of crude protein (72.69% to 86.76%), lipid (77.09% to 87.72%), and gross energy (74.12% to 55.44%) were observed in SPC, and the lowest were found in RSM. However, the ADCs of phosphorus ranged from 36.14% (RSM) to 47.35% (SBM). The ADCs of proximate nutrients for BY, CGM, PNM, SBM, and SPC were significantly higher ( < 0.05) than other protein ingredients (RSM, CGM). Similar patterns of digestibility were observed for individual AAs of the test ingredients. Overall, the diet containing SPC appeared to be more suitable and compatible with the reference diet. Conversely, PNM, BY, SBM, and CGM showed some potential as aquafeed ingredients, whereas CSM and RSM appear to be the least viable options. Such information aids in better feed formulation by focusing on nutrient absorption rather than raw ingredient composition.
水产饲料行业依赖鱼粉作为主要蛋白质来源,但其使用引发了经济和环境方面的担忧,促使人们寻找可持续的替代方案。本研究比较了银大麻哈鱼对选定蛋白质成分的干物质(DM)、能量、蛋白质、磷、脂质和氨基酸(AAs)的表观消化率系数(ADCs)。为此,以参考饲料与一种测试成分70:30的比例,配制了一种参考饲料和七种测试饲料,分别对应啤酒酵母(BY)、玉米蛋白粉(CGM)、棉籽粕(CSM)、花生粕(PNM)、菜籽粕(RSM)、豆粕(SBM)和大豆浓缩蛋白(SPC)。1200尾鱼被随机分配到24个玻璃水族箱中(每个水族箱直径3.0米,深度1.5米,水体8.5立方米),每种实验饲料设置三个水族箱(总计 = 50×24 = 1200)。实验持续8周。结果表明,DM的ADCs范围从RSM的43.34%到SPC的72.90%。同样,粗蛋白(72.69%至86.76%)、脂质(77.09%至87.72%)和总能(74.12%至55.44%)最高的ADCs在SPC中观察到,最低的在RSM中。然而,磷的ADCs范围从36.14%(RSM)到47.35%(SBM)。BY、CGM、PNM、SBM和SPC的近似养分ADCs显著高于其他蛋白质成分(RSM、CGM)(P < 0.05)。对测试成分的单个AAs也观察到类似的消化率模式。总体而言,含SPC的饲料似乎更适合且与参考饲料相容。相反,PNM、BY、SBM和CGM显示出作为水产饲料成分的一些潜力,而CSM和RSM似乎是最不可行的选择。此类信息有助于通过关注养分吸收而非原料组成来更好地进行饲料配方设计。