Wang Qiang, Sun Daming, Li Guangjian, Li Lin, Li Hongyan, Xu Yajun
Law School of Nanjing University, Nanjing University, Nanjing, China.
Forensic Science Center, East China University of Political Science and Law, Shanghai, China.
Front Psychiatry. 2025 Jul 21;16:1545173. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2025.1545173. eCollection 2025.
This study aims to reveal the suicide risk factors in specific situations of medical malpractice.
We conducted a systematic analysis using the medical malpractice case data from the judgment search system on China Judgments Online, covering the years 2012 to 2022. The χ test was applied to compare group differences, while a binary logistics regression analysis was used to assess factors influencing suicide among hospitalized patients with mental disorders.
A total of 268 finalized medical malpractice judgments were analyzed. From 2012 to 2022, medical malpractice cases involving psychiatric inpatients in China show a significant upward trend. Suicide cases of hospitalized patients with mental disorders accounted for 32.5% of all medical malpractice cases. These incidents were more frequent in comprehensive hospitals, tertiary hospitals, and economically developed regions such as East China and Central China. Chi-square testing and multivariate binary logistic regression analysis revealed that hospital type, history of suicidal behavior, clinical psychiatric diagnosis of others, medical fault in violating specific regulations, and medical fault in breach of duty of care were identified as independent risk factors (OR=2.662,3.866,3.567,3.247,3.593; 95% CI: 1.368-5.180, 1.473-10.146, 0.398-9.107,1.193-8.838,1.406-9.179).
In China, the proportion of suicide cases of hospitalized psychiatric patients in civil cases of medical malpractices has been increasing. Independent risk factors include hospital type, suicidal history, history of suicidal behavior, clinical psychiatric diagnosis of others, medical fault in violating specific regulations and medical fault in breach of duty of care. Optimizing resource allocation in comprehensive hospitals, enhancing ward safety, and standardizing clinical protocols are urgently needed to mitigate preventable suicides in this vulnerable population.
本研究旨在揭示医疗事故特定情形下的自杀风险因素。
我们利用中国裁判文书网判决检索系统中2012年至2022年的医疗事故案例数据进行系统分析。采用χ检验比较组间差异,同时运用二元逻辑回归分析评估精神障碍住院患者自杀的影响因素。
共分析了268份终审医疗事故判决。2012年至2022年,中国涉及精神科住院患者的医疗事故案例呈显著上升趋势。精神障碍住院患者自杀案例占所有医疗事故案例的32.5%。这些事件在综合医院、三级医院以及华东和华中地区等经济发达地区更为频繁。卡方检验和多变量二元逻辑回归分析显示,医院类型、自杀行为史、他人临床精神科诊断、违反特定规定的医疗过错以及违反注意义务的医疗过错被确定为独立风险因素(OR=2.662,3.866,3.567,3.247,3.593;95%CI:1.368 - 5.180, 1.473 - 10.146, 0.398 - 9.107,1.193 - 8.838,1.406 - 9.179)。
在中国,医疗事故民事案件中精神科住院患者自杀案例的比例一直在上升。独立风险因素包括医院类型、自杀史、自杀行为史、他人临床精神科诊断、违反特定规定的医疗过错以及违反注意义务的医疗过错。迫切需要优化综合医院的资源配置、加强病房安全并规范临床诊疗方案,以减少这一脆弱人群中可预防的自杀行为。