Didio Antonella, Giannuzzi Viviana, Archer Natasha, Gani Esther, Sblano Sabina, Peprah Emmanuel, Kountouris Petros, Bonifazi Fedele
Fondazione Per La Ricerca Farmacologica Gianni Benzi Onlus, Via Giulio Petroni 91/D, 70124, Bari, Italy.
Pediatric Hematology and Oncology, Boston Children's Hospital, Boston, USA.
Health Res Policy Syst. 2025 Aug 5;23(1):101. doi: 10.1186/s12961-025-01375-z.
The International Hemoglobinopathy Research Network (INHERENT) focuses on studying genetic modifiers through large, multi-ethnic genome-wide association studies involving paediatric and adult patients with haemoglobinopathies. The growing integration of genetics and genomics into global healthcare has highlighted the need for standardized policies on biospecimen and data handling. This study describes the necessary ethical and regulatory framework for conducting multinational, researcher-driven genetic studies on humans.
Key areas related to the INHERENT study were identified through collaborative research. A review of the grey literature was performed, consulting official sources. An online survey was conducted to identify the local rules.
Despite the availability of 33 international documents applicable to the three key areas of our investigation, i.e. personal data processing, clinical research and biospecimen management, there is no unique reference for genetic studies without investigational drugs, i.e. outside the scope of good clinical practice. Specific laws and guidelines/recommendations governing the processing of personal data and privacy have been released in most of the 32 surveyed countries. As an example, discordances were found regarding the requirement to get approval from the ethics committees.
Such heterogeneity challenges the scientific community in conducting these genetic studies. This study calls for further efforts to harmonize international standards for genetic research.
国际血红蛋白病研究网络(INHERENT)专注于通过大规模、多民族全基因组关联研究来研究基因修饰因子,这些研究涉及患有血红蛋白病的儿科和成年患者。遗传学和基因组学在全球医疗保健中的日益融合凸显了对生物样本和数据处理制定标准化政策的必要性。本研究描述了开展跨国、研究者驱动的人类基因研究所需的伦理和监管框架。
通过合作研究确定了与INHERENT研究相关的关键领域。查阅了灰色文献,并咨询了官方来源。进行了一项在线调查以确定当地规则。
尽管有33份国际文件适用于我们调查的三个关键领域,即个人数据处理、临床研究和生物样本管理,但对于不涉及研究药物的基因研究,即超出良好临床实践范围的研究,没有唯一的参考标准。在接受调查的32个国家中的大多数国家都发布了关于个人数据处理和隐私的具体法律以及指南/建议。例如,在获得伦理委员会批准的要求方面发现了不一致之处。
这种异质性给科学界开展这些基因研究带来了挑战。本研究呼吁进一步努力协调基因研究的国际标准。