Hanmer Janel, Burns Sarah K, Wittman Samuel R, Doan Tran T, Krishnamurti Tamar, Ray Kristin N
Department of Medicine, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
Department of Pediatrics, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine (UPMC), UPMC Children's Hospital of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
JAMA Netw Open. 2025 Aug 1;8(8):e2525904. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2025.25904.
Care is commonly sought for pediatric acute respiratory tract infections (ARTIs). The site where families seek ARTI care affects continuity, quality, and costs, but how parents of young children balance tradeoffs between care sites is unknown.
To evaluate preferences for attributes of ARTI care sites among parents of young children using a discrete choice experiment (DCE).
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This survey study using a DCE was conducted among a nationally representative panel of US parents of children aged 6 months to 5 years between July 31 and August 18, 2023. Participants completed a DCE survey with 7 care attributes (visit modality, visit timeliness, noncare time, out-of-pocket costs, clinician continuity, pediatric expertise, and follow-up availability), with 2 to 5 levels each. The DCE used standard choice-based conjoint procedures. Sawtooth software was used to create a random, balanced overlap experimental design. Data were analyzed between October 2023 and October 2024.
The main outcomes were preferences for attributes and their levels, examined using hierarchical bayesian and latent class analyses and market simulation of care choices under different scenarios.
Of 944 respondents, 63 (6.7%) self-identified as Asian or Pacific Islander, 228 (24.2%) as Hispanic, 120 (12.8%) as Black non-Hispanic, 501 (53.1%) as White non-Hispanic, and 30 (3.3%) as other non-Hispanic; 53% were women; 285 spoke a language other than English at home; and 338 had children who received Medicaid. Respondents' mean (SD) age was 36.5 (7.4). Overall, respondents gave most weight to visit modality (in person vs telemedicine; importance, 22.7%) and out-of-pocket costs (importance, 23.7%) and least weight to noncare time (importance, 5.8%) and availability of follow-up within 2 days (importance, 6.8%). Latent class analysis identified 4 subgroups: urgency focused (47.4% of respondents), continuity focused (22.7%), cost focused (20.6%), and in-person visit focused (9.3%). The addition of a telehealth visit option with the child's usual primary care practice available within 30 minutes to options of in-person primary care, urgent care, and emergency department care shifted reduced anticipated care seeking outside of primary care in urgency-focused (-13.3%) and cost-focused (-5.6%) subgroups and reduced forgone care in the cost-focused subgroup (-8.1%).
In this survey study using a DCE, a subset of parents prioritized in-person care for pediatric ARTI care, and most parents had other profiles focused on different care attributes. Results of this research suggest that access to low-cost, quickly available telehealth services with a clinician in a child's usual practice could shift some urgent care and emergency department visits for ARTI to the child's primary care practice.
儿童急性呼吸道感染(ARTIs)通常需要就医。家庭寻求ARTIs治疗的地点会影响连续性、质量和成本,但幼儿父母如何在不同治疗地点之间权衡利弊尚不清楚。
通过离散选择实验(DCE)评估幼儿父母对ARTIs治疗地点属性的偏好。
设计、背景和参与者:这项使用DCE的调查研究于2023年7月31日至8月18日在美国全国代表性的6个月至5岁儿童父母小组中进行。参与者完成了一项DCE调查,其中包括7个护理属性(就诊方式、就诊及时性、非护理时间、自付费用、临床医生连续性、儿科专业知识和随访可用性),每个属性有2至5个水平。DCE采用基于标准选择的联合程序。使用Sawtooth软件创建随机、平衡的重叠实验设计。数据于2023年10月至2024年10月进行分析。
主要结局是对属性及其水平的偏好,使用分层贝叶斯分析和潜在类别分析以及不同场景下护理选择的市场模拟进行检验。
在944名受访者中,63人(6.7%)自我认定为亚裔或太平洋岛民,228人(24.2%)为西班牙裔,120人(12.8%)为非西班牙裔黑人,501人(53.1%)为非西班牙裔白人,30人(3.3%)为其他非西班牙裔;53%为女性;285人在家说英语以外的语言;338人的孩子接受医疗补助。受访者的平均(标准差)年龄为36.5(7.4)岁。总体而言,受访者最看重就诊方式(面对面就诊与远程医疗;重要性为22.7%)和自付费用(重要性为23.7%),最不看重非护理时间(重要性为5.8%)和两天内随访的可用性(重要性为6.8%)。潜在类别分析确定了4个亚组:注重紧迫性(47.4%的受访者)、注重连续性(22.7%)、注重成本(20.6%)和注重面对面就诊(9.3%)。在面对面初级保健、紧急护理和急诊科护理选项中增加一个可在30分钟内与孩子的常规初级保健医生进行的远程医疗就诊选项,使注重紧迫性(-13.3%)和注重成本(-5.6%)亚组中预计在初级保健之外寻求护理的情况减少,并使注重成本亚组中放弃护理的情况减少(-8.1%)。
在这项使用DCE的调查研究中,一部分父母将儿科ARTIs护理的面对面护理列为优先事项,而大多数父母有其他关注不同护理属性的特征。这项研究结果表明,获得低成本、快速可用的远程医疗服务,且临床医生为孩子的常规执业医生,可能会将一些ARTIs的紧急护理和急诊科就诊转移到孩子的初级保健机构。