MacNeill Lillian, Wayne Katherine, Luke Alison, Bridges Sarah, Besner Julia, Fowler Samantha, Doucet Shelley
University of New Brunswick, Saint John, Canada.
Horizon Health Network, Saint John, Canada.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2025 Aug 11;25(1):1059. doi: 10.1186/s12913-025-13249-9.
Health research in Canada is progressively moving towards engaging patients and their caregivers in projects where they can positively contribute to the improvement of healthcare systems and practices. One aspect of patient-oriented research (POR) focuses on identifying patient priorities for health research. Relative to their population size, patients with complex care needs (CCN) account for disproportionately high health services usage. Therefore, these patients and their caregivers are well-positioned to offer informed perspectives on health service delivery improvements.
Using a cross-sectional qualitative descriptive design, we explored health service delivery research priorities for two patient populations: children/youth with CCN and older adults with CCN, in New Brunswick, Canada. Despite concerted efforts to recruit patients directly, only caregivers responded to the recruitment materials. Qualitative data was collected using semi-structured interviews, focus groups, and self-report surveys. Data were analyzed using qualitative content analysis.
Thirty-seven caregivers of children/youth and 35 caregivers of older adults took part in the study. While the study initially aimed to identify research priorities, participants primarily emphasized service gaps and made concrete recommendations for health system improvements. The top five priority areas for improving health service delivery for caregivers of children/youth with CCN were: (1) access to appropriate health care supports and services; (2) care continuity and coordination; (3) transitions to adulthood; (4) school and daycare system barriers; and (5) caregiver support. The top five priority areas for improving health service delivery for older adults with CCN according to their caregivers were: (1) access to appropriate health care supports and services; (2) home care issues and barriers; (3) care navigation and coordination; (4) impact of COVID-19 on care; and (5) caregiver support.
This study highlights the multifaceted nature of caring for individuals with CCN. Our findings provide direction for future health research projects and offer practical guidance for health system decision-makers in the effort to improve health service delivery, particularly for our most vulnerable populations.
加拿大的健康研究正逐步朝着让患者及其护理人员参与项目的方向发展,在这些项目中,他们可以为改善医疗保健系统和实践做出积极贡献。以患者为导向的研究(POR)的一个方面侧重于确定健康研究的患者优先事项。相对于其人口规模,有复杂护理需求(CCN)的患者占医疗服务使用量的比例过高。因此,这些患者及其护理人员能够很好地就改善医疗服务提供提供明智的观点。
采用横断面定性描述设计,我们探索了加拿大新不伦瑞克省两类患者群体的医疗服务提供研究优先事项:患有CCN的儿童/青少年和患有CCN的老年人。尽管我们齐心协力直接招募患者,但只有护理人员回应了招募材料。使用半结构化访谈、焦点小组和自我报告调查收集定性数据。使用定性内容分析对数据进行分析。
37名儿童/青少年的护理人员和35名老年人的护理人员参与了该研究。虽然该研究最初旨在确定研究优先事项,但参与者主要强调了服务差距,并为改善卫生系统提出了具体建议。改善患有CCN的儿童/青少年护理人员医疗服务提供的前五大优先领域是:(1)获得适当的医疗保健支持和服务;(2)护理连续性和协调性;(3)向成年期过渡;(4)学校和日托系统障碍;(5)护理人员支持。根据护理人员的说法,改善患有CCN的老年人医疗服务提供的前五大优先领域是:(1)获得适当的医疗保健支持和服务;(2)家庭护理问题和障碍;(3)护理导航和协调;(4)COVID-19对护理的影响;(5)护理人员支持。
本研究强调了照顾患有CCN的个体的多面性。我们的研究结果为未来的健康研究项目提供了方向,并为卫生系统决策者努力改善医疗服务提供,特别是为我们最脆弱的人群提供了实用指导。