Garcia Mélanie, Dosenbach Nico, Kelly Clare
Department of Psychiatry, School of Medicine, Trinity College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland.
Trinity College Institute of Neuroscience, Trinity College, Dublin, Ireland.
Imaging Neurosci (Camb). 2024 Oct 1;2. doi: 10.1162/imag_a_00300. eCollection 2024.
Analyses of structural MRI (sMRI) data depend on robust upstream data quality control (QC). It is also crucial that researchers seek to retain maximal amounts of data to ensure reproducible, generalizable models and to avoid wasted effort, including that of participants. The time-consuming and difficult task of manual QC evaluation has prompted the development of tools for the automatic assessment of brain sMRI scans. Existing tools have proved particularly valuable in this age of Big Data; as datasets continue to grow, reducing execution time for QC evaluation will be of considerable benefit. The development of Deep Learning (DL) models for artifact detection in structural MRI scans offers a promising avenue toward fast, accurate QC evaluation. In this study, we trained an interpretable Deep Learning model, ProtoPNet, to classify minimally preprocessed 2D slices of scans that had been manually annotated with a refined quality assessment (ABIDE 1;= 980 scans). To evaluate the best model, we applied it to 2141 ABCD T1-weighted MRI scans for which gold-standard manual QC annotations were available. We obtained excellent accuracy: 82.4% for good quality scans (Pass), 91.4% for medium to low quality scans (Fail). Further validation using 799 T1w MRI scans from ABIDE 2 and 750 T1w MRI scans from ADHD-200 confirmed the reliability of our model. Accuracy was comparable to or exceeded that of existing ML models, with fast processing and prediction time (1 minute per scan, GPU machine, CUDA-compatible). Our attention model also performs better than traditional DL (i.e., convolutional neural network models) in detecting poor quality scans. To facilitate faster and more accurate QC prediction for the neuroimaging community, we have shared the model that returned the most reliable global quality scores as a BIDS-app (https://github.com/garciaml/BrainQCNet).
结构磁共振成像(sMRI)数据的分析依赖于强大的上游数据质量控制(QC)。研究人员努力保留最大量的数据以确保模型具有可重复性和可推广性,并避免包括参与者在内的资源浪费,这一点也至关重要。手动QC评估这项耗时且困难的任务促使了用于自动评估脑部sMRI扫描的工具的开发。在这个大数据时代,现有工具已证明具有特别重要的价值;随着数据集不断增长,减少QC评估的执行时间将带来巨大益处。开发用于结构MRI扫描中伪影检测的深度学习(DL)模型为快速、准确的QC评估提供了一条有前景的途径。在本研究中,我们训练了一个可解释的深度学习模型ProtoPNet,用于对经过最少预处理的二维扫描切片进行分类,这些切片已通过精细的质量评估进行了手动标注(ABIDE 1;= 980次扫描)。为了评估最佳模型,我们将其应用于2141例有金标准手动QC标注的ABCD T1加权MRI扫描。我们获得了出色的准确率:高质量扫描(通过)为82.4%,中低质量扫描(未通过)为91.4%。使用来自ABIDE 2的799例T1w MRI扫描和来自ADHD - 200的750例T1w MRI扫描进行的进一步验证证实了我们模型的可靠性。准确率与现有机器学习模型相当或更高,且处理和预测时间较快(每扫描1分钟,GPU机器,CUDA兼容)。我们的注意力模型在检测低质量扫描方面也比传统深度学习(即卷积神经网络模型)表现更好。为了便于神经影像学界进行更快、更准确的QC预测,我们已将返回最可靠全局质量分数的模型作为一个BIDS应用程序共享(https://github.com/garciaml/BrainQCNet)。