Lupyan Tatyana, Zelker Revital, Abomokh Shadi, Brickman Adena, Shafran-Tikva Sigal, Alon Rely, Cohen Muriel, Benbenishty Julie
Hadassah Hebrew University Medical Center, Jerusalem, Israel.
School of Nursing Jerusalem College of Technology, Hadassah Hebrew University Medical Center, Jerusalem, Israel.
J Eval Clin Pract. 2025 Aug;31(5):e70239. doi: 10.1111/jep.70239.
Families of patients being mechanically ventilated in hospital ward or ICU settings, may experience significant morbidities. A comparison of the needs in these two populations is necessary to address the challenges they experience.
Explore the needs of families of ventilated patients located in the ICU compared to those whose family member is being ventilated in an internal medicine ward.
This was a cross-sectional secondary analysis of data collected between 2013 and 2019 in ICU and internal medicine departments. Participants in both settings were aged over 18 years, gave their consent to participate in the questionnaire-based study, and were either family or legal relatives of a hospitalised patient. Inclusion criteria required a hospital length of stay of more than 2 days.
A total of 221 family members were recruited: 89 from the ICU and 132 from internal medicine departments. The results indicated that families of a patient in an internal medicine ward required significantly more support and proximity than those with a family member in the ICU. In contrast, the ICU associated families demonstrated significantly higher needs for information than those with a family member in an internal medicine ward.
Families of ventilated patients in internal medicine wards and ICUs have unfulfilled needs that should be considered. Different clinical settings present diverse challenges, which clinicians need to know how to address. The climate and nature of the clinical ward or unit influence the family's needs.
在医院病房或重症监护病房(ICU)接受机械通气治疗的患者家属,可能会经历重大疾病。比较这两类人群的需求对于应对他们所面临的挑战至关重要。
探究与在内科病房接受通气治疗患者的家属相比,重症监护病房中接受通气治疗患者家属的需求。
这是一项对2013年至2019年期间在重症监护病房和内科收集的数据进行的横断面二次分析。两种环境下的参与者年龄均超过18岁,同意参与基于问卷的研究,并且是住院患者的家属或法定亲属。纳入标准要求住院时间超过2天。
共招募了221名家属:89名来自重症监护病房,132名来自内科。结果表明,内科病房患者的家属比重症监护病房患者的家属需要更多的支持和陪伴。相比之下,重症监护病房患者的家属对信息的需求明显高于内科病房患者的家属。
内科病房和重症监护病房中接受通气治疗患者的家属存在未得到满足的需求,应予以考虑。不同的临床环境带来了不同的挑战,临床医生需要知道如何应对。临床病房或科室的氛围和性质会影响家属的需求。