Zisook S, DeVaul R
Am J Psychoanal. 1985 Winter;45(4):370-9. doi: 10.1007/BF01252871.
This paper has reviewed the literature on bereavement and, with particular emphasis on the authors' own work, describes three syndromes which seem to be related to the nonresolution of distinct phases of the grief process. The possibility of unresolved grief should receive a high index of suspicion for the patient with otherwise unexplainable depression, chronic illness behavior, or symptoms similar to those of a deceased relative or friend. When any of these syndromes are identified, it is useful to ask the patient who he has lost, how he has lost them, how he felt about the loss, whether he felt that he grieved, whether he still cries or feels the need to cry, and whether he has adjusted. The answer to these questions--both verbal and nonverbal--will help identify unresolved grief, when present, and may be a guide to specific interventions. On the other hand, our studies have suggested that unresolved grief is a somewhat overly simplistic concept. Most, if not all, people never totally resolve their grief; significant aspects of the bereavement process go on for years after the loss, even in otherwise normal patients. For some, identification syndromes continue. Others may continue to feel the presence of the deceased or have daily visions of him or her. Still others may feel pain, anger, and guilt for years after the death. It is still unclear at what point and to what degree these behaviors and symptoms become medical or psychiatric concerns and become pathological or predispose to serious medical, psychological, or social complications. Investigations into these unreported areas have been initiated and, we trust, will lead to clinically useful answers.
本文回顾了关于丧亲之痛的文献,并特别强调了作者自己的研究工作,描述了三种似乎与悲伤过程不同阶段未得到解决相关的综合征。对于患有无法解释的抑郁症、慢性病行为或出现与已故亲属或朋友相似症状的患者,应高度怀疑其存在未解决的悲伤情绪。当识别出这些综合征中的任何一种时,询问患者失去了谁、如何失去的、对失去的感受如何、是否觉得自己悲伤过、是否仍会哭泣或觉得有哭泣的必要以及是否已经调整过来是很有用的。这些问题的答案——包括言语和非言语的——将有助于识别存在的未解决的悲伤情绪,并可能为具体干预提供指导。另一方面,我们的研究表明,未解决的悲伤是一个有些过于简单化的概念。大多数人(如果不是所有人的话)永远不会完全解决他们的悲伤;丧亲过程的重要方面在失去亲人多年后仍会持续,即使是在其他方面正常的患者中也是如此。对一些人来说,识别综合征会持续存在。另一些人可能会持续感觉到逝者的存在,或者每天都能看到逝者。还有一些人可能在亲人去世多年后仍会感到痛苦、愤怒和内疚。目前尚不清楚这些行为和症状在何时以及在何种程度上会成为医学或精神方面的问题,并变得病态或导致严重的医学、心理或社会并发症。我们已经开始对这些未报告的领域进行调查,并且相信会得出对临床有用的答案。