Riang'a Roselyter Monchari, Mwangi Eunice Muthoni, Nagarajan Niranjani, Agoi Felix, Mwangala Patrick N, Gross Alden L, Ikanga Jean, Langa Kenneth M, Miguel Edward, Gichu Muthoni, Ehrlich Joshua R, Ngugi Anthony K
Department of Population Health, Medical College East Africa, Aga Khan University, Nairobi, Kenya.
Department of Ophthalmology and Visual Sciences, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA.
Alzheimers Dement. 2025 Aug;21(8):e70552. doi: 10.1002/alz.70552.
Cross-cultural adaptation of cognitive assessments is crucial for detecting Alzheimer's disease (AD) and related dementias (ADRD) in aging populations. This study documents the adaptation of the Harmonized Cognitive Assessment Protocol (HCAP) for a pilot study on the Longitudinal Study of Health and Aging in Kenya (LOSHAK) in rural Kilifi County, Kenya, highlighting challenges and strategies for optimizing outcomes. As part of the LOSHAK feasibility phase, cognitive tests including: the Swahili Mental State Examination, 10-word recall, animal naming, story recall, clock drawing, and making change, were administered to 202 participants (≥45 years) from the Kaloleni/Rabai Health and Demographic Surveillance System (KRHDSS). Measures were adapted culturally and linguistically, and trained local enumerators conducted home-based assessments. Low literacy (60.1% had no schooling), linguistic diversity, cultural norms, and infrastructure limitations influenced assessments. Key adaptations included translation, culturally relevant modifications, flexible administration, and community engagement. Contextualized cognitive assessments improve validity in rural resource-limited settings, offering insights for future research. HIGHLIGHTS: This is a narrative qualitative study documenting the experiences and Strategies Adopted to Optimize Effective Adaption of Cognitive Tests in Longitudinal Study of Health and Aging in Kenya (LOSHAK). This article documents the adaptation and contextualization of the Harmonized Cognitive Assessment Protocol (HCAP) for a pilot study on health and aging (LOSHAK) in rural Kilifi County, Kenya, focusing on the challenges and strategies employed to optimize outcome. HCAP tests were administered as part of the feasibility and pilot phase of the LOSHAK, the aim of which was to validate measures and optimize data collection procedures. The median age of the 202 study participants was 64, with 57.4% being female. A majority (62.5%) were not currently working, and nearly 70% fell within the two poorest wealth quintiles. The rural setting presented unique challenges including: low literacy rates (60.1% of participants had no schooling), diverse language use (primarily Giriama and Swahili), limited infrastructure (e.g., 44.8% of households had electricity), restrictive cultural norms that influenced data collection (e.g., in-home interviews were often conducted outdoors with destructions). Key adaptations included: translating and culturally adapting test items (e.g., using local Swahili dialects and culturally relevant examples), recruiting and training local enumerators who were familiar with the community, culture and language, iterative pre-testing and using roleplay helped to ensure that enumerator scoring was consistent, accurate, and reliable. contextualization of tool and data collection strategies included: adjusting data collection methods to accommodate cultural practices and environmental limitations, for example, allowing respondents to use their preferred language for "animal naming," using paper and pen for some test items for which participants experienced difficulty using tablets, paying close special attention to time and season of administration, and adopting strategies to minimize background noise and other environmental distractions (e.g., due to rain, lunch hour, planting and harvesting, and school holidays). Prior to data collection, it was essential to engage local community health volunteers (CHVs), build rapport with participants, explain the study, and describe the idiosyncrasies of cognitive testing. The study emphasizes the importance of cultural sensitivity, linguistic appropriateness, and community engagement in cognitive assessment in diverse, resource-constrained settings. The findings offer practical recommendations for researchers aiming to conduct cognitive assessments in similar populations, contributing to the development of culturally sensitive and effective tools for understanding and addressing cognitive health in aging populations.
认知评估的跨文化适应性对于在老年人群中检测阿尔茨海默病(AD)及相关痴呆症(ADRD)至关重要。本研究记录了统一认知评估协议(HCAP)在肯尼亚基利菲县农村地区的健康与老龄化纵向研究(LOSHAK)试点研究中的适应性情况,突出了优化结果所面临的挑战和策略。作为LOSHAK可行性阶段的一部分,对来自卡洛莱尼/拉拜健康与人口监测系统(KRHDSS)的202名参与者(≥45岁)进行了认知测试,包括:斯瓦希里语精神状态检查、10个单词回忆、动物命名、故事回忆、画钟和找零钱。这些测试在文化和语言上进行了调整,由经过培训的当地调查员进行上门评估。低识字率(60.1%的人未接受过学校教育)、语言多样性、文化规范和基础设施限制影响了评估。关键的调整包括翻译、与文化相关的修改、灵活的实施方式以及社区参与。情境化的认知评估提高了农村资源有限环境下的有效性,为未来研究提供了见解。要点:这是一项叙述性定性研究,记录了在肯尼亚健康与老龄化纵向研究(LOSHAK)中为优化认知测试有效适应性所采用的经验和策略。本文记录了统一认知评估协议(HCAP)在肯尼亚基利菲县农村地区健康与老龄化试点研究(LOSHAK)中的适应性和情境化情况,重点关注为优化结果所采用的挑战和策略。HCAP测试作为LOSHAK可行性和试点阶段的一部分进行,其目的是验证测量方法并优化数据收集程序。202名研究参与者的年龄中位数为64岁,其中57.4%为女性。大多数(62.5%)目前没有工作,近70%属于最贫困的两个财富五分位数。农村环境带来了独特的挑战,包括:低识字率(60.1%的参与者未接受过学校教育)、语言使用多样(主要是吉里亚马语和斯瓦希里语)、基础设施有限(例如,44.8%的家庭有电)、影响数据收集的限制性文化规范(例如,入户访谈经常在户外进行且受到干扰)。关键的调整包括:对测试项目进行翻译和文化调整(例如,使用当地斯瓦希里方言和与文化相关的例子)、招募和培训熟悉社区、文化和语言的当地调查员、反复进行预测试并使用角色扮演有助于确保调查员评分一致、准确和可靠。工具和数据收集策略的情境化包括:调整数据收集方法以适应文化习俗和环境限制,例如,允许受访者使用他们喜欢的语言进行“动物命名”,对于参与者使用平板电脑有困难的一些测试项目使用纸笔,密切关注测试实施的时间和季节,并采取策略尽量减少背景噪音和其他环境干扰(例如,由于下雨、午餐时间、种植和收获以及学校假期)。在数据收集之前,与当地社区健康志愿者(CHV)合作、与参与者建立融洽关系、解释研究并描述认知测试的特点至关重要。该研究强调了在多样化、资源有限的环境中进行认知评估时文化敏感性、语言适宜性和社区参与的重要性。研究结果为旨在对类似人群进行认知评估的研究人员提供了实用建议,有助于开发文化敏感且有效的工具,以理解和解决老年人群的认知健康问题。