Aquarius René, Bik Elisabeth M, Bimler David, Oksvold Morten P, Patrick Kevin
Department of Neurosurgery, Radboud university medical center, Nijmegen, Gelderland, the Netherlands.
Harbers Bik LLC, San Francisco, CA, USA.
Bioengineered. 2025 Dec;16(1):2542668. doi: 10.1080/21655979.2025.2542668. Epub 2025 Aug 21.
Taylor & Francis journal has been targeted by paper mills. Our goal is to identify problematic articles published in during the period 2010 to 2024. Dimensions was used to search for articles that contained the terms 'mouse' OR 'mice' OR 'rat' OR 'rats' in title or abstract, published in between January 1st 2010 to December 31st 2024. All articles were assessed by eye and by using software to detect inappropriate image duplication and manipulation. An article was classified as problematic if it contained inappropriate image duplication or manipulation or had been previously retracted. Problematic articles were reported on PubPeer by the authors if they had not been reported previously. All included articles were assessed for post-publication editorial decisions. We have excluded all articles published in 2024 from further analysis, as these were all retraction notices. We assessed the remaining 878 articles, of which 226 (25.7%) were identified as problematic, of which 35 had been previously retracted. One retracted article was later de-retracted. One article received a correction. None of the included articles received an expression of concern or the Taylor & Francis 'under investigation' pop-up. Taylor & Francis' lack of visible editorial action has left the scientific community vulnerable to reading and citing hundreds of problematic articles published in . To uphold scientific integrity, Taylor & Francis should use the findings of this study as a starting point to systematically identify all compromised articles in and take appropriate editorial action.
泰勒与弗朗西斯出版社的期刊成为了论文工厂的目标。我们的目标是识别2010年至2024年期间在该出版社发表的有问题的文章。利用Dimensions数据库搜索在2010年1月1日至2024年12月31日期间发表的、标题或摘要中包含“mouse”(小鼠)或“mice”(小鼠复数)或“rat”(大鼠)或“rats”(大鼠复数)的文章。所有文章均通过人工检查以及使用软件来检测不适当的图像复制和处理情况。如果一篇文章包含不适当的图像复制或处理情况,或者此前已被撤回,则将其归类为有问题的文章。如果有问题的文章此前未被报道,作者会在PubPeer上进行报告。对所有纳入的文章进行了出版后编辑决策评估。我们将2024年发表的所有文章排除在进一步分析之外,因为这些都是撤稿通知。我们评估了其余878篇文章,其中226篇(25.7%)被确定为有问题,其中35篇此前已被撤回。一篇撤回的文章后来被撤销了撤稿。一篇文章得到了更正。纳入的文章中没有一篇收到关注声明或泰勒与弗朗西斯出版社的“正在调查”弹窗。泰勒与弗朗西斯出版社缺乏明显的编辑行动,使得科学界容易读到并引用该出版社发表的数百篇有问题的文章。为维护科学诚信,泰勒与弗朗西斯出版社应以本研究结果为起点,系统识别该出版社所有存在问题的文章,并采取适当的编辑行动。