Livieratos Achilleas, Zeitzer Jamie M, Tsiodras Sotirios
Independent Researcher, 15238 Athens, Greece.
Department of Psychiatry & Behavioral Sciences, School of Medicine, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, USA.
Vaccines (Basel). 2025 Aug 8;13(8):845. doi: 10.3390/vaccines13080845.
We aimed to synthesize and critically evaluate human studies on the impact of circadian and sleep factors on influenza vaccine-induced immune responses. A comprehensive literature review was conducted, and of the 1260 studies identified, 13 met the inclusion criteria for evaluating vaccination timing, circadian misalignment, and sleep parameters in relation to influenza vaccine-induced immune responses in human populations. Most studies assessed humoral immune responses, primarily antibody titers. Morning vaccination (typically between 9:00 and 11:00 AM) was associated with higher antibody titers compared to afternoon vaccination, particularly for the A/H1N1 strain in adults aged ≥ 65 years. Short sleep duration-especially in the two nights preceding vaccination-was associated with reduced antibody levels, while acute sleep deprivation the night after vaccination transiently reduced antibody levels in males. Sleep fragmentation and excessive daytime sleepiness were linked to increased vulnerability to breakthrough infections. Evidence on circadian misalignment from shift work was mixed. Clinical outcomes were reported in one large trial, where morning vaccination correlated with fewer respiratory hospitalizations. Current evidence supports a potential role for circadian timing and sleep duration in enhancing vaccine-induced antibody responses, particularly in older adults and individuals with sleep or circadian disruption. However, inconsistencies, modest effect sizes, and methodological limitations preclude broad recommendations. Future studies should incorporate direct measures of circadian phase, stratify by chronotype and population (e.g., shift workers), and evaluate both immunologic and clinical outcomes to inform targeted chrono-immunization strategies.
我们旨在综合并批判性地评估关于昼夜节律和睡眠因素对流感疫苗诱导的免疫反应影响的人体研究。我们进行了全面的文献综述,在鉴定出的1260项研究中,有13项符合纳入标准,可用于评估接种时间、昼夜节律失调和睡眠参数与人群中流感疫苗诱导的免疫反应之间的关系。大多数研究评估了体液免疫反应,主要是抗体滴度。与下午接种相比,上午接种(通常在上午9:00至11:00之间)与更高的抗体滴度相关,尤其是在≥65岁的成年人中针对A/H1N1毒株的情况。睡眠时间短——尤其是在接种前的两个晚上——与抗体水平降低有关,而接种后当晚的急性睡眠剥夺会使男性的抗体水平暂时降低。睡眠碎片化和白天过度嗜睡与突破性感染的易感性增加有关。关于轮班工作导致的昼夜节律失调的证据不一。在一项大型试验中报告了临床结果,其中上午接种与较少的呼吸道住院相关。目前的证据支持昼夜节律时间和睡眠时间在增强疫苗诱导的抗体反应方面的潜在作用,特别是在老年人以及睡眠或昼夜节律紊乱的个体中。然而,不一致性、适度的效应大小和方法学限制妨碍了广泛的建议。未来的研究应纳入昼夜节律相位的直接测量,按生物钟类型和人群(如轮班工作者)分层,并评估免疫和临床结果,以为有针对性的时辰免疫策略提供信息。