Serier Kelsey N, Zelkowitz Rachel L, Knutson Emma K, Vogt Dawne, Smith Brian N, Mitchell Karen S
Women's Health Sciences Division, National Center for PTSD, VA Boston Healthcare System, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
Department of Psychiatry, Boston University Chobanian & Avedisian School of Medicine, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
J Psychopathol Behav Assess. 2025 Mar;47(1). doi: 10.1007/s10862-025-10192-1. Epub 2025 Jan 24.
Self-criticism, or negative self-evaluation characterized by often unrealistic personal standards and a harsh self-view, is a relevant transdiagnostic construct for mental health. Yet, the psychometric properties of scales assessing self-criticism have not been examined in military veterans, a population with a high burden of psychiatric symptoms. The present study tested the factor structure of the full and short-form versions of the Forms of Self-Criticizing/Attacking & Self-Reassuring Scale (FSCRS and FSCRS-SF), a measure of self-criticism, in a sample of 1,161 United States veterans who completed this and other measures as part of a larger study. Measurement invariance across men and women and associations with mental health symptoms, disordered eating, substance abuse, and self-directed violence were also examined. We found adequate support for two- and three-factor models and improved model fit with correlated residuals. Given theoretical and model fit considerations, measurement invariance was tested with the three-factor model. Both the FSCRS and FSCRS-SF were invariant across men and women. Women scored higher than men on the Hated Self (HS) and Inadequate Self (IS) subscales. HS and IS subscales scores were positively correlated with mental health constructs, whereas Reassured Self (RS) subscale scores were negatively correlated with these constructs. Overall, both the FSCRS and FSCRS-SF, when a briefer scale is preferred, appear appropriate for use in veterans. There are important gender differences in self-criticism that warrant further investigation; however, scores on this measure can be meaningfully compared across men and women. Validation of the FSCRS in veterans may encourage additional research on self-criticism in this population.
自我批评,即以往往不切实际的个人标准和苛刻的自我看法为特征的负面自我评价,是一个与心理健康相关的跨诊断概念。然而,评估自我批评的量表的心理测量特性尚未在退伍军人中进行检验,这是一个精神症状负担较重的群体。本研究在1161名美国退伍军人样本中测试了自我批评测量工具《自我批评/攻击与自我安慰量表》(FSCRS和FSCRS-SF)完整版和简版的因子结构,这些退伍军人作为一项更大规模研究的一部分完成了该量表及其他测量。还检验了男女之间的测量不变性以及与心理健康症状、饮食失调、药物滥用和自我导向暴力的关联。我们发现对两因素和三因素模型有充分支持,且相关残差改进了模型拟合。考虑到理论和模型拟合因素,用三因素模型检验了测量不变性。FSCRS和FSCRS-SF在男女之间都是不变的。女性在“讨厌自己”(HS)和“自我不足”(IS)分量表上的得分高于男性。HS和IS分量表得分与心理健康指标呈正相关,而“自我安慰”(RS)分量表得分与这些指标呈负相关。总体而言,当更喜欢简短量表时,FSCRS和FSCRS-SF似乎都适用于退伍军人。自我批评存在重要的性别差异,值得进一步研究;然而,该测量的得分在男女之间可以进行有意义的比较。FSCRS在退伍军人中的验证可能会鼓励对该群体的自我批评进行更多研究。