Li Yonghui, Zhang Han, Shi Weili, He Wei, Miao Yu, Wei Guodong, Jiang Zhengang
School of Computer Science and Technology, Changchun University of Science and Technology, Changchun, China.
Jilin Provincial Key Laboratory of Tooth Development and Bone Remodeling, School and Hospital of Stomatology, Jilin University, Changchun, China.
Quant Imaging Med Surg. 2025 Sep 1;15(9):8023-8039. doi: 10.21037/qims-2025-386. Epub 2025 Aug 19.
The precision of image-physical space registration using spherical markers in craniomaxillofacial surgical navigation significantly depends on the accurate estimation of spherical parameters from computed tomography (CT) images. However, this estimation is susceptible to the abnormal points caused by artifacts, instruments interference, and other factors. To address these challenges, this study proposes a robust method to improve reproducibility in results and achieve higher accuracy on low inlier ratio data, thereby meeting the requirements of high-precision surgical applications.
Firstly, potential marker sphere regions are isolated from CT images. Next, we propose the Local Evaluation and Optimization RANdom SAmple Consensus (LEO-RANSAC) algorithm to refine the detection of the spherical parameters. This technique introduces a metric that combines multi-level adaptive curvature and local solution to filter local models, and adopts an equidistance adjustment mechanism to improve the accuracy of the so-far-the-best model. Lastly, a custom-designed equipment is utilized to measure the fiducial localization error (FLE), and a skull phantom study is utilized to evaluate the fiducial registration error (FRE) and the target registration error (TRE).
The proposed method was evaluated on 72-point clouds with inlier ratio ranging from 30% to 90%. After repeating 100 independent experiments, the deviations of the maximum of FLEs for six different configurations were 0.40±0.25, 0.52±0.35, 0.58±0.35, 0.53±0.25, 0.51±0.28, and 0.39±0.31 mm, respectively. Analysis of 72 results showed that 87.50% of the maximum of FLEs were less than 0.9 mm, and 95.83% of the variances of FLEs were less than 0.01. In a skull phantom study involving 3 different datasets, the FREs were 0.4222, 0.5223, and 0.372 mm, respectively, whereas the TREs were 0.8546, 0.9471, and 0.8537 mm during real-time guidance, respectively.
The results demonstrate that our method outperforms existing approaches in terms of accuracy and reliability, highlighting its potential applicability in craniomaxillofacial surgical navigation.
在颅颌面外科手术导航中,使用球形标记进行图像 - 物理空间配准的精度很大程度上取决于从计算机断层扫描(CT)图像中准确估计球形参数。然而,这种估计容易受到伪影、器械干扰和其他因素导致的异常点的影响。为应对这些挑战,本研究提出一种稳健的方法,以提高结果的可重复性,并在低内点比率数据上实现更高的精度,从而满足高精度手术应用的要求。
首先,从CT图像中分离出潜在的标记球区域。接下来,我们提出局部评估与优化随机抽样一致性(LEO - RANSAC)算法来优化球形参数的检测。该技术引入一种结合多级自适应曲率和局部解的度量来过滤局部模型,并采用等距调整机制来提高当前最佳模型的准确性。最后,利用定制设计的设备测量基准定位误差(FLE),并通过颅骨模型研究来评估基准配准误差(FRE)和目标配准误差(TRE)。
所提出的方法在72个内点比率范围从30%到90%的点云上进行了评估。在重复100次独立实验后,六种不同配置的FLE最大值的偏差分别为0.40±0.25、0.52±0.35、0.58±0.35、0.53±0.25、0.51±0.28和0.39±0.31毫米。对72个结果的分析表明,87.50%的FLE最大值小于0.9毫米,95.83%的FLE方差小于0.01。在涉及3个不同数据集的颅骨模型研究中,FRE分别为0.4222、0.5223和0.372毫米,而在实时引导期间,TRE分别为0.8546、0.9471和0.8537毫米。
结果表明,我们的方法在准确性和可靠性方面优于现有方法,突出了其在颅颌面外科手术导航中的潜在适用性。