Jap Bernard A J, Bastiaanse Roelien
Department of Humanities, Language and Translation, Hong Kong Metropolitan University, Kowloon, Hong Kong.
Center for Language and Cognition Groningen (CLCG), University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands.
J Psycholinguist Res. 2025 Sep 3;54(5):54. doi: 10.1007/s10936-025-10165-1.
For individuals with agrammatic aphasia, producing sentences with non-canonical word orders is a challenging feat. Studies on different languages report deficits in this area of sentence production: some citing problems related to retrieval of verb morphology while others pursue a more holistic approach by attributing the root of the deficit towards the process of thematic role assignment. It has been shown that agrammatic speakers of Standard Indonesian are relatively unimpaired in the use (in spontaneous speech) and comprehension of passive constructions. These studies suggest the high frequency of the passive structure in Standard Indonesian may play a role in its retrieval and processing. For the current study, we tested sentence production in agrammatic speakers of Standard Indonesian. The purpose of the present study is to assess the effects of syntactic frequency and word order on sentence production in agrammatic speakers of Standard Indonesian. Twelve agrammatic speakers were tested with a picture elicitation task. The participants had to produce active and passive, reversible and non-reversible sentences. No main effects of sentence type were observed; reversible and non-reversible active and passive sentences were produced with comparable accuracy. Despite this observation, the majority of errors produced were associated with role-reversals and verb inflection. Lack of a specific deficit in the production of structures with non-canonical word order suggests the impact of syntactic frequency on agrammatic sentence processing. As with previous studies on Indonesian sentence comprehension, the present results provide evidence for the preservation of the passive structure in agrammatic speakers of Standard Indonesian.
对于患有语法性失语症的个体而言,生成具有非标准语序的句子是一项具有挑战性的任务。针对不同语言的研究报告了句子生成这一领域存在的缺陷:一些研究指出与动词形态检索相关的问题,而另一些研究则采用更全面的方法,将缺陷根源归因于题元角色分配过程。研究表明,标准印尼语的语法性失语症患者在(自发言语中)被动结构的使用和理解方面相对未受损害。这些研究表明,标准印尼语中被动结构的高频率使用可能在其检索和处理中发挥作用。在本研究中,我们测试了标准印尼语语法性失语症患者的句子生成能力。本研究的目的是评估句法频率和语序对标准印尼语语法性失语症患者句子生成的影响。12名语法性失语症患者接受了图片诱发任务测试。参与者必须生成主动句和被动句、可逆句和不可逆句。未观察到句子类型的主效应;可逆和不可逆的主动句和被动句生成的准确率相当。尽管有此观察结果,但产生的大多数错误都与角色颠倒和动词屈折有关。在生成具有非标准语序的结构时缺乏特定缺陷,这表明句法频率对语法性失语症句子处理有影响。与之前关于印尼语句子理解的研究一样,本研究结果为标准印尼语语法性失语症患者被动结构的保留提供了证据。