Elendu Chukwuka, Amaechi Dependable C, Elendu Tochi C, Olabode Deborah M, Elendu Ijeoma D, Amaechi Emmanuel C, Aggreh Ovonomor P, Bright Chidera C
Department of Medicine, Federal University Teaching Hospital, Owerri, Nigeria.
Department of Medicine, Igbinedion University, Okada, Nigeria.
Ann Med Surg (Lond). 2025 Jul 14;87(9):5688-5695. doi: 10.1097/MS9.0000000000003582. eCollection 2025 Sep.
Corporal punishment is a prevalent form of discipline in Nigerian schools, despite international and national efforts to protect children's rights. Rooted in cultural norms and traditional practices, physical punishment is widely accepted by parents, educators, and community leaders as an effective disciplinary tool. It has remained deeply ingrained in Nigerian schools, with significant attention paid to its prevalence, detrimental effects, and the sociocultural factors that perpetuate its use. We conducted a literature review of 57 studies published over the past two decades, revealing alarmingly high rates of corporal punishment across different regions of Nigeria, with Northern Nigeria reporting the highest prevalence (85%) and Southern Nigeria the lowest (70%). Younger students, particularly those in primary school, are most frequently subjected to such disciplinary measures. Common forms include caning (60%), slapping (45%), and flogging (25%), all of which have significant physical, psychological, and emotional impacts - ranging from injuries to increased anxiety, depression, and low self-esteem. Traditional beliefs and societal attitudes normalize these practices, complicating the enforcement of protective laws such as the Violence Against Persons (Prohibition) Act of 2015. Our analysis underscores the pressing need for concerted efforts to eliminate corporal punishment in Nigerian schools. We recommend strengthening legal reforms, promoting alternative disciplinary approaches, engaging communities to shift cultural norms, and implementing effective monitoring mechanisms. By fostering positive discipline practices, Nigerian schools can create a safe and supportive environment that prioritizes the well-being and dignity of children.
尽管国际和国内都在努力保护儿童权利,但体罚在尼日利亚学校中仍是一种普遍的纪律形式。体罚植根于文化规范和传统习俗,被家长、教育工作者和社区领袖广泛接受为一种有效的纪律手段。它在尼日利亚学校中根深蒂固,人们对其普遍性、有害影响以及使其持续存在的社会文化因素给予了极大关注。我们对过去二十年发表的57项研究进行了文献综述,结果显示尼日利亚不同地区的体罚发生率高得惊人,其中尼日利亚北部的发生率最高(85%),南部最低(70%)。年龄较小的学生,尤其是小学生,最常受到这种纪律处分。常见形式包括鞭打(60%)、掌掴(45%)和棍打(25%),所有这些都对身体、心理和情绪有重大影响——从受伤到焦虑、抑郁和自卑加剧。传统观念和社会态度使这些做法正常化,使得诸如2015年《禁止暴力侵害人身法》等保护性法律的执行变得复杂。我们的分析强调了齐心协力消除尼日利亚学校体罚现象的迫切需要。我们建议加强法律改革,推广替代纪律处分方法,让社区参与以改变文化规范,并实施有效的监督机制。通过培养积极的纪律做法,尼日利亚学校可以创造一个安全且支持性的环境,将儿童的福祉和尊严放在首位。