Hess Chris, Acolin Arthur, Walter Rebecca, Kennedy Ian, Chasins Sarah, Crowder Kyle
Department of Policy Analysis and Management, Cornell University, USA.
Department of Real Estate, University of Washington, USA.
Environ Plan A. 2021 Nov;53(8):2012-2032. doi: 10.1177/0308518x211034177. Epub 2021 Jul 28.
Understanding residential mobility, housing affordability, and the geography of neighborhood advantage and disadvantage relies on robust information about housing search processes and housing markets. Existing data about housing markets, especially rental markets, suffer from accuracy issues and a lack of temporal and geographic flexibility. Data collected from online rental platforms that are commonly used can help address these issues and hold considerable promise for better understanding the full distribution of available rental homes. However, realizing this promise requires a careful assessment of potential sources of bias as online rental listing platforms may perpetuate inequalities similar to those found in physical spaces. This paper approaches the production of rental advertisements as a social process driven by both contextual and property level factors. We compare data from two online platforms for the 100 most populated metropolitan areas in the United States to explore inequality in digital rental listing spaces and understand what characteristics are associated with over and underrepresentation of advertisements in certain areas. We find similar associations for socioeconomic measures between platforms and across urban and suburban parts of these metropolitan areas. In contrast, the importance of racial and ethnic composition, as well as broader patterns of segregation, for online representation differs substantially across space and platform. This analysis informs our understanding of how online platforms affect housing search dynamics through their biases and segmentation, and highlights the potential and limits in using the data available on these platforms to produce small area rental estimates.
了解居住流动性、住房可负担性以及邻里优势与劣势的地理分布,依赖于有关住房搜索过程和住房市场的可靠信息。现有的住房市场数据,尤其是租赁市场数据,存在准确性问题,且缺乏时间和地理灵活性。从常用的在线租赁平台收集的数据有助于解决这些问题,并为更好地了解可用出租房屋的完整分布情况带来了很大希望。然而,要实现这一希望,需要仔细评估潜在的偏差来源,因为在线租赁房源平台可能会延续与实体空间中类似的不平等现象。本文将租赁广告的制作视为一个由背景因素和房产层面因素共同驱动的社会过程。我们比较了美国人口最多的100个大都市区两个在线平台的数据,以探究数字租赁房源空间中的不平等现象,并了解在某些地区广告的过度呈现和呈现不足与哪些特征相关。我们发现,在平台之间以及这些大都市区的城市和郊区,社会经济指标存在类似的关联。相比之下,种族和族裔构成以及更广泛的隔离模式对在线呈现的重要性在不同空间和平台上有很大差异。这一分析有助于我们理解在线平台如何通过其偏差和细分影响住房搜索动态,并突出了利用这些平台上的数据进行小区域租金估计的潜力和局限性。