Bernisson Maud, Sismondo Sergio
Institute for Science in Society, Radboud University, Postbus 9102, 6500 HC Nijmegen, Netherlands.
Laboratoire Interdisciplinaire Sciences Innovations Sociétés (LISIS), CNRS, Université Gustave Eiffel, 5 Boulevard Descartes, 77420 Champs-sur-Marne, France.
Health Promot Int. 2025 Sep 3;40(5). doi: 10.1093/heapro/daaf146.
Medical writing is a key element in pharmaceutical companies' efforts to shape the relevant medical science literature. As part of what is called 'publication planning', medical writing can influence the knowledge base on which prescribers make decisions, and can build specific claims in targeted sales efforts. Most publication planning is done by hired medical education and communication companies (MECCs), with the rest done by other commercial entities, such as units of pharmaceutical companies or of contract research organizations, that provide essentially the same services as MECCs. Here we provide an estimate of the number of MECCs and comparable entities contributing to the medical science literature in English. To identify these companies, we collected data from Web of Science (858 named firms from 20 498 papers mentioning medical writing assistance), LinkedIn (410 company profiles), and Google and DuckDuckGo (68 company websites). After removing duplicates and false positives, we found 1148 MECCs and other comparable entities providing medical writing services. More than 50% of Web of Science papers that acknowledged medical writing support are sponsored by only ten pharmaceutical companies. Most of the remaining papers in our database are sponsored by other pharmaceutical, device, and biotechnology companies. This study likely undercounts MECCs, because it depends on some level of transparency in publications or other leakage of information. Our combining multiple sources for the data should limit the undercount of MECCs. The study does not identify MECCs that work exclusively in languages other than English.
医学写作是制药公司塑造相关医学科学文献工作中的关键要素。作为所谓“出版计划”的一部分,医学写作能够影响开处方者做决策所依据的知识库,并且能够在有针对性的销售活动中确立特定主张。大多数出版计划由聘请的医学教育与沟通公司(MECCs)完成,其余部分则由其他商业实体完成,比如制药公司或合同研究组织的部门,它们提供与MECCs基本相同的服务。在此,我们估算了为英文医学科学文献做出贡献的MECCs及类似实体的数量。为识别这些公司,我们从《科学引文索引》(20498篇提及医学写作协助的论文中有858家被提及的公司)、领英(410个公司简介)以及谷歌和 DuckDuckGo(68个公司网站)收集了数据。在去除重复项和误报之后,我们发现有1148家MECCs及其他类似实体提供医学写作服务。在《科学引文索引》中承认获得医学写作支持的论文里,超过50%仅由十家制药公司赞助。我们数据库中其余的大多数论文由其他制药、器械和生物技术公司赞助。这项研究可能低估了MECCs的数量,因为它依赖于出版物中的某种程度的透明度或其他信息泄露。我们将多个数据源结合起来获取数据应能减少对MECCs数量的低估。该研究未识别出仅使用英语以外语言开展工作的MECCs。