Schampheleer Emilie, Habay Jelle, Proost Matthias, Arauz Y Laurisa Arenales, Russell Suzanna, Roose Manon, Bian Chao, Meeusen Romain, De Pauw Kevin, Roelands Bart
Faculty of Physical Education and Physiotherapy, Human Physiology and Sports Physiotherapy Research Group, Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Pleinlaan 2, 1050, Brussels, Belgium.
Vital Signs and Performance Monitoring Research Unit, LIFE Department, Royal Military Academy, Brussels, Belgium.
Sports Med. 2025 Sep 5. doi: 10.1007/s40279-025-02286-3.
Mental fatigue (MF) is a complex phenomenon with significant implications for human performance, for which there are numerous studies investigating the effects of MF. Nevertheless, there is considerable variability in the approaches used to induce and quantify MF, making it hard to compare findings across studies and draw well-supported conclusions. This review addresses the methodological variability in the induction and quantification methods of MF in movement science in the following ways: on the one hand, by providing an overview of task design strategies to induce MF, emphasizing the importance of tailoring task duration, difficulty, and nature to individual participants and specific research contexts; on the other hand, by providing an overview of current methods used to quantify MF, including behavioural, subjective, and physiological measures, and highlighting the strengths and limitations of each. Finally, this review proposes a best-practice framework for MF research, incorporating multi-method approaches for the induction and quantification of MF and introducing the Settings, Protocol establishments, Confounders, Individuals, Framework, and Yield (SPeCIFY) reporting guidelines that aim at improving consistency and transparency in future MF studies.
精神疲劳(MF)是一种复杂的现象,对人类表现有重大影响,针对此有众多研究探讨MF的影响。然而,用于诱发和量化MF的方法存在相当大的差异,这使得难以比较不同研究的结果并得出有充分依据的结论。本综述通过以下方式探讨运动科学中MF诱发和量化方法的方法学差异:一方面,概述诱发MF的任务设计策略,强调根据个体参与者和特定研究背景调整任务持续时间、难度和性质的重要性;另一方面,概述当前用于量化MF的方法,包括行为、主观和生理测量方法,并突出每种方法的优点和局限性。最后,本综述提出了一个MF研究的最佳实践框架,纳入用于MF诱发和量化的多方法途径,并引入旨在提高未来MF研究的一致性和透明度的设置、方案制定、混杂因素、个体、框架和产出(SPeCIFY)报告指南。