van Wijk Jessica, van Loon Fredericus H J, Hendrickx Fleur, Arets Danielle, Lalleman Pieterbas C B
Department of Health Studies, The Research Group for Person-Centeredness in an Ageing Society, Fontys University of Applied Sciences, Eindhoven, The Netherlands.
Department of Perioperative Care and Technology, Fontys University of Applied Sciences, Eindhoven, The Netherlands.
Int Nurs Rev. 2025 Sep;72(3):e70097. doi: 10.1111/inr.70097.
To explore how nurses were represented in five Dutch newspapers between 2019 and 2022, with a focus on their visibility in policy and decision-making.
The media significantly shape public understanding of healthcare. Despite their key role, nurses are often underrepresented in media, especially in policy-related coverage. This study addresses this gap in the Dutch context.
Directed content analysis of 272 articles published between 2019 and 2022 across five high-circulation Dutch newspapers. A coding instrument was developed from existing literature and applied using Atlas.ti. ENTREQ criteria were followed throughout.
Nurses were least often cited in articles about policy, finance, and innovation. Senior leadership sources, predominantly male, were cited most frequently, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic. Nurses were more commonly cited in human-interest, nursing identity and image, strike-related, and ethical stories. In many articles, images either excluded nurses or portrayed them in ways that obscured their identity.
The findings indicate that nurses' voices are not effectively utilized, particularly in policy discussions. This aligns with previous studies showing the underrepresentation of nurses as expert sources, with a predominance of male higher management and medical professionals being cited more frequently.
The imbalance in nurse representation, particularly in policy and decision-making, highlights the need for systemic change.
Media competency training is needed in nursing (under)graduate curricula and in nursing leadership development programs to effectively convey their expertise and work. A collaborative and systemic approach involving key stakeholders is advised to ensure that nurse voices are elevated, especially related to health policy.
探讨2019年至2022年期间荷兰五家报纸对护士的报道情况,重点关注护士在政策制定和决策过程中的能见度。
媒体在很大程度上塑造了公众对医疗保健的理解。尽管护士发挥着关键作用,但他们在媒体中的呈现往往不足,尤其是在与政策相关的报道中。本研究针对荷兰的这一差距展开探讨。
对2019年至2022年期间在荷兰五家发行量较大的报纸上发表的272篇文章进行定向内容分析。根据现有文献开发了一种编码工具,并使用Atlas.ti软件进行应用。整个过程遵循ENTREQ标准。
在关于政策、财务和创新的文章中,护士被引用的频率最低。主要为男性的高级领导来源被引用的频率最高,尤其是在新冠疫情期间。护士在人情味、护理身份与形象、罢工相关以及伦理故事中被引用的频率更高。在许多文章中,图片要么没有展示护士,要么以模糊其身份的方式描绘他们。
研究结果表明,护士的声音没有得到有效利用,尤其是在政策讨论中。这与之前的研究一致,这些研究表明护士作为专家来源的呈现不足,男性高级管理人员和医学专业人员被引用的频率更高。
护士呈现的不平衡,尤其是在政策制定和决策方面,凸显了系统性变革的必要性。
护理本科(及以下)课程和护理领导力发展项目需要开展媒体能力培训,以有效传达护士的专业知识和工作。建议采取一种涉及关键利益相关者的协作性和系统性方法,以确保提升护士的声音,特别是与卫生政策相关的声音。