Moya-Salazar Jeel, Ciprian Lizbeth Y, Rojas-Zumaran Víctor, Moya-Salazar Belén, Goicochea-Palomino Eliane A, Contreras-Pulache Hans
Faculties of Medicine, Universidad Señor de Sipán, Chiclayo, Peru.
Clinical Laboratory Area, Clínica Celestial de Ayacucho, Ayacucho, Peru.
Front Med (Lausanne). 2025 Aug 21;12:1592019. doi: 10.3389/fmed.2025.1592019. eCollection 2025.
Vaccination against COVID-19 has generated a dramatic reduction in deaths and infections worldwide. However, there may be cross-reactivity with numerous biochemical and immunological markers. The Widal test for the detection of typhoid fever is an antigen-antibody test that can be affected by vaccination, causing errors in the results, so we determined the frequency of false positive results of the Widal test in adults vaccinated with Commirnaty (Pfizer -BioNtech) and BBIBP-CorV (Sinopharm) vaccines.
We conducted a cross-sectional study analyzing the titers of the serum agglutinins ( O and H antigen, and A and B antigen) in 50 adults.
The proportion of false positives for O, H, A, and B antigens was 60, 44, 8, and 40%, respectively (total false positives = 38%). The Wildal tests' results of patients with Commirnaty vaccine had higher false-positive dilution titers for O antigen [titer 1/400 (7.1%) and 1/800 (9.5%)] and H antigen [titer 1/400 (4.8%) and 1/800 (17.6%)]. We found differences in the paratyphic B by age and gender ( < 0.05).
Our results suggest misleading results of the Widal test in patients vaccinated against COVID-19, mainly in those vaccinated with Commirnaty. It is important to monitor and evaluate the results of routine immunological tests to ensure the quality of medical care.
针对新冠病毒的疫苗接种已在全球范围内大幅降低了死亡和感染人数。然而,它可能与众多生化和免疫标志物存在交叉反应。用于检测伤寒热的维达试验是一种抗原-抗体试验,可能会受到疫苗接种的影响,导致结果出现误差,因此我们确定了接种辉瑞-BioNTech公司的Comirnaty疫苗和中国国药集团的BBIBP-CorV疫苗的成年人中维达试验假阳性结果的频率。
我们开展了一项横断面研究,分析了50名成年人血清凝集素(O和H抗原以及A和B抗原)的滴度。
O、H、A和B抗原的假阳性比例分别为60%、44%、8%和40%(总假阳性率=38%)。接种Comirnaty疫苗患者的维达试验结果中,O抗原[titer 1/400(7.1%)和1/800(9.5%)]和H抗原[titer 1/400(4.8%)和1/800(17.6%)]的假阳性稀释滴度更高。我们发现副伤寒B在年龄和性别方面存在差异(P<0.05)。
我们的结果表明,接种新冠疫苗的患者进行维达试验可能会得出误导性结果,主要是接种Comirnaty疫苗的患者。监测和评估常规免疫检测结果对于确保医疗质量很重要。