Adhiambo Harriet Fridah, Owidi Emmah, Okello Phelix, Coe Megan, Shin Michelle B, Oluoch Lynda Myra, Thuo Nicholas B, Ihaji Valary, Kerubo Mary Bernadette, Kinyua Alex, Caucutt Jason, Heitner Jesse, Odeny Thomas, Weiner Bryan, Ngure Kenneth, Mugo Nelly, Gimbel Sarah
Department of Child, Family, and Population Health Nursing, School of Nursing, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington, United States of America.
Center for Microbiology Research, Kenya Medical Research Institute, Nairobi, Kenya.
PLOS Glob Public Health. 2025 Sep 9;5(9):e0005166. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0005166. eCollection 2025.
Cervical cancer continues to be a major global threat to women's health, with approximately 660,000 women diagnosed annually, 94% of whom are in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). The high disease burden in LMICs is partly due to suboptimal adoption and widespread implementation of effective preventive interventions. This study explored drivers of implementation success and failure for a future single-visit, screen, and treat approach with thermal ablation (SV-SAT + TA), referred to as TIBA in Kenya. Guided by the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR framework), we conducted in-depth interviews with 34 participants (frontline health workers, health facility managers, and policymakers) between May and August 2022 in Kiambu, Embu, and Murang'a Counties in Kenya. All interviews were audio recorded and transcribed verbatim. We applied deductive and inductive coding for emerging themes. The participants reported the relative advantage of thermal ablation for the single-visit, screen-and-treat approach, emphasizing its lower start-up and maintenance costs and lower complexity compared to cryotherapy. Additionally, participants expressed confidence in their ability to implement TIBA, and a strong commitment from the leadership to support TIBA implementation was reported. These factors were perceived as drivers of successful TIBA implementation. In contrast, barriers, including lack of essential commodities and equipment, shortage of trained providers, staff redeployment, inadequate space, recruitment challenges, and silos within the healthcare system, were identified as drivers of implementation failure. To optimize cervical cancer prevention efforts in LMICs, it is critical to address both systemic and contextual factors through a coordinated, integrated, and system-wide approach that involves all the key stakeholders.
宫颈癌仍然是全球女性健康的重大威胁,每年约有66万名女性被诊断出患有宫颈癌,其中94%在低收入和中等收入国家(LMICs)。LMICs中疾病负担较高,部分原因是有效预防干预措施的采用不理想和广泛实施不足。本研究探讨了未来单次就诊、筛查和治疗热消融方法(SV-SAT + TA,在肯尼亚称为TIBA)实施成功和失败的驱动因素。在实施研究综合框架(CFIR框架)的指导下,我们于2022年5月至8月在肯尼亚的基安布、恩布和穆朗加县对34名参与者(一线卫生工作者、医疗机构管理人员和政策制定者)进行了深入访谈。所有访谈均进行了录音并逐字转录。我们对新出现的主题应用了演绎和归纳编码。参与者报告了热消融在单次就诊、筛查和治疗方法中的相对优势,强调其与冷冻疗法相比启动和维护成本更低,复杂性更低。此外,参与者对他们实施TIBA的能力表示有信心,并报告称领导层对支持TIBA实施有坚定承诺。这些因素被视为TIBA成功实施的驱动因素。相比之下,包括基本物资和设备短缺、训练有素的提供者短缺、人员重新部署、空间不足、招聘挑战以及医疗系统内的部门壁垒等障碍被确定为实施失败的驱动因素。为了优化LMICs中的宫颈癌预防工作,通过一种涉及所有关键利益相关者的协调、综合和全系统方法来解决系统和背景因素至关重要。