Nelson Ferguson Kendra, Christianson Kyla, Delgado Adrian, Martin Gina, Coen Stephanie E, Struik Laura
Western University, London, ON, Canada.
University of British Columbia Okanagan, Kelowna, BC, Canada.
JMIR Form Res. 2025 Sep 11;9:e75694. doi: 10.2196/75694.
As youth engagement with traditional public health warnings declines, innovative strategies are needed. Visually compelling, youth-driven digital content such as interactive infographics may help bridge knowledge gaps, enhance risk perception, and support more informed decision-making. Despite this potential, limited research has assessed its effectiveness in conveying vaping-related harms to youth.
To address this gap, this study evaluated the impact of a codeveloped, youth-informed digital infographic (What's in a Vape?) on enhancing vaping education and improving youth understanding of vaping-related harms.
A convergent parallel mixed methods design was used to assess the impact of a youth-informed digital infographic. The infographic was created in collaboration with youth coresearchers and youth advisory councils to ensure relevance. Participants were recruited through community partners, school boards, and youth networks. By May 2024, we had enrolled 63 high school students aged 14 to 19 years (mean age 16.5, SD 1.2 years) primarily from Ontario and British Columbia. The survey evaluated baseline knowledge of vaping, engagement with the infographic, and postexposure perceptions on whether the content contributed to increased awareness or understanding of vaping.
Data collection took place between April 2024 and May 2024. Quantitative analysis showed that 87% (55/63) of participants agreed that the infographic effectively communicated key information, and 86% (54/63) gained new knowledge about vaping. In addition, 73% (46/63) found that the infographic was presented in an easy and meaningful way, whereas 52% (33/63) indicated that they would definitely share it with others, reflecting strong engagement. However, over half (33/63, 52%) also found the amount of information excessive, and 17% (11/63) found it difficult to digest, indicating variation in youth information preferences. Thematic analysis of qualitative feedback revealed four key themes: (1) the visual content enabled gaining new insights into and knowledge of vaping, (2) the visual design had a positive impact on engagement with information, (3) sourced information enhanced the credibility of the infographic information, and (4) the digital design of the infographic made complex information more understandable. Qualitative insights contextualized and supported the quantitative findings, highlighting both benefits and areas for improvement.
This study demonstrates that youth-driven digital infographics may serve as useful health communication tools. Findings highlight the importance of peer-led design; evidence-based content; and interactive, visually compelling formats in enhancing youth comprehension and receptiveness to health messaging. By integrating youth feedback into development and prioritizing digital engagement, the infographic bridged knowledge gaps while reinforcing the credibility of its content. Variability in feedback about content overload suggests that future versions should consider more layered or modular designs. Results suggest that such approaches may complement broader public health strategies to curb youth vaping and inform future educational interventions. Continued research is warranted to assess long-term impacts on attitudes and behavior.
随着年轻人对传统公共卫生警告的关注度下降,需要创新策略。视觉上引人注目的、由年轻人主导的数字内容,如交互式信息图表,可能有助于弥合知识差距、增强风险认知,并支持更明智的决策。尽管有这种潜力,但评估其向年轻人传达电子烟相关危害有效性的研究有限。
为填补这一空白,本研究评估了共同开发的、基于年轻人意见的数字信息图表(《电子烟里有什么?》)对加强电子烟教育以及提高年轻人对电子烟相关危害理解的影响。
采用收敛平行混合方法设计来评估基于年轻人意见的数字信息图表的影响。该信息图表是与青年共同研究者和青年咨询委员会合作创建的,以确保相关性。通过社区合作伙伴、学校董事会和青年网络招募参与者。到2024年5月,我们招募了63名年龄在14至19岁之间的高中生(平均年龄16.5岁,标准差1.2岁),主要来自安大略省和不列颠哥伦比亚省。该调查评估了对电子烟的基线知识、对信息图表的参与度,以及接触后对内容是否有助于提高对电子烟的认识或理解的看法。
数据收集于2024年4月至2024年5月进行。定量分析表明,87%(55/63)的参与者同意信息图表有效地传达了关键信息,86%(54/63)获得了关于电子烟的新知识。此外,73%(46/63)的人认为信息图表呈现方式简单且有意义,而52%(33/63)的人表示肯定会与他人分享,这反映出参与度很高。然而,超过一半(33/63,52%)也认为信息量过大,17%(11/63)的人觉得难以理解,这表明年轻人的信息偏好存在差异。对定性反馈的主题分析揭示了四个关键主题:(1)视觉内容使人们对电子烟有了新的见解和知识,(2)视觉设计对信息参与度有积极影响,(3)来源信息增强了信息图表信息的可信度,(4)信息图表的数字设计使复杂信息更易于理解。定性见解为定量结果提供了背景并支持了这些结果,突出了优点和改进领域。
本研究表明,由年轻人主导的数字信息图表可能是有用的健康传播工具。研究结果强调了同伴主导设计、基于证据的内容以及交互式、视觉上引人注目的形式在提高年轻人对健康信息的理解和接受度方面的重要性。通过将年轻人的反馈纳入开发过程并优先考虑数字参与度,信息图表弥合了知识差距,同时增强了其内容的可信度。关于内容过载的反馈存在差异,这表明未来版本应考虑更分层或模块化的设计。结果表明,此类方法可能补充更广泛的公共卫生策略以遏制年轻人使用电子烟,并为未来的教育干预提供信息。有必要进行持续研究以评估对态度和行为的长期影响。