Foulger Liam H, Liu Xiyao, Nasrabadi Amin M, Qiao Calvin Z, Carpenter Mark G, Wu Lyndia C, Blouin Jean-Sébastien
School of Kinesiology, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada.
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada.
J Physiol. 2025 Oct;603(19):5629-5653. doi: 10.1113/JP288632. Epub 2025 Sep 11.
To maintain a bipedal posture, humans must compensate for inherent sensorimotor delays from neural conduction times and electromechanical delays. Ageing and certain neurological disorders increase these delays, so it is crucial that we adapt our control of balance to compensate for the uncertainty associated with acting on sensory information from the past. Although humans can adapt to imposed delays of 400 ms, the mechanisms underlying the adaptation process remain unknown because gross balance instability or errors are absent when returning to balancing without delays. To investigate this, we used a robotic balance simulator to impose delays of 250 ms while participants balanced upright. We characterized and modelled the adjustments in motor commands required to adapt to the addition and removal of delays. Following 20 min of adaptation, participants successfully maintained their balance with the imposed delay. When the delay was abruptly removed, participants remained upright with minimal changes in their whole-body oscillations, but we observed transient (5-20 s) spectral power increases between 1 and 2 Hz in the net ankle torque and lower limb muscle activity. Our computational model revealed that increased sensorimotor gains led to spectral changes in the balance motor commands. Our results indicate that increased sensorimotor gains are necessary to adapt balance control to longer delays and that these gains remained transiently elevated after the removal of the delays without resulting in postural instability. This highlights the remarkable adaptability of human balance control, revealing that the nervous system can flexibly adjust sensorimotor strategies to maintain balance under changing conditions. KEY POINTS: The human nervous system can adapt to sensorimotor delays, allowing us to maintain balance even though there are delays between sensed stimuli and our corrective motor actions. While balancing on a robotic simulator, participants exposed to a 250 ms delay between their self-generated motor commands and resulting whole-body motion exhibited initial difficulty maintaining balance and increased muscle (co)activation but adapted within minutes of exposure. Despite no postural instability following the abrupt removal of the 250 ms delay, participants exhibited transient (5-20 s) increases in leg muscle activation and ankle torque power (1-2 Hz). These changes in the neuromuscular control of balance after delay removal suggest increased sensitivity to sensory feedback, as supported by a computational model representing key physiological features of balance control. By revealing how the brain adapts when facing rapidly changing environments, our results highlight the flexibility of the neural control of balance to ensure robust bipedal stability.
为了维持双足姿势,人类必须补偿神经传导时间和机电延迟所带来的内在感觉运动延迟。衰老和某些神经系统疾病会增加这些延迟,因此至关重要的是,我们要调整平衡控制,以补偿与基于过去的感觉信息采取行动相关的不确定性。尽管人类能够适应长达400毫秒的外加延迟,但适应过程背后的机制仍然未知,因为在无延迟恢复平衡时不存在明显的平衡不稳定或误差。为了对此进行研究,我们使用了一个机器人平衡模拟器,在参与者直立平衡时施加250毫秒的延迟。我们对适应延迟添加和去除所需的运动指令调整进行了表征和建模。经过20分钟的适应,参与者成功地在施加延迟的情况下保持了平衡。当延迟突然去除时,参与者保持直立,全身振荡的变化最小,但我们观察到净踝部扭矩和下肢肌肉活动在1至2赫兹之间出现了短暂(5 - 20秒)的频谱功率增加。我们的计算模型表明,感觉运动增益增加导致平衡运动指令出现频谱变化。我们的结果表明,增加感觉运动增益对于使平衡控制适应更长的延迟是必要的,并且在去除延迟后这些增益会短暂升高而不会导致姿势不稳定。这突出了人类平衡控制的显著适应性,表明神经系统可以灵活调整感觉运动策略以在不断变化的条件下维持平衡。要点:人类神经系统能够适应感觉运动延迟,使我们即使在感觉刺激与我们的纠正性运动动作之间存在延迟的情况下也能维持平衡。在机器人模拟器上保持平衡时,参与者在自我产生的运动指令与由此产生的全身运动之间经历250毫秒延迟时,最初难以保持平衡且肌肉(共同)激活增加,但在暴露几分钟内就适应了。尽管在突然去除250毫秒延迟后没有姿势不稳定,但参与者的腿部肌肉激活和踝部扭矩功率(1 - 2赫兹)出现了短暂(5 - 20秒)增加。延迟去除后平衡的神经肌肉控制的这些变化表明对感觉反馈的敏感性增加,这得到了一个代表平衡控制关键生理特征的计算模型的支持。通过揭示大脑在面对快速变化的环境时如何适应,我们的结果突出了平衡神经控制的灵活性,以确保稳健的双足稳定性。