Russell-Lacy S, Robinson V, Benson J, Cranage J
Br J Psychiatry. 1979 Feb;134:195-200. doi: 10.1192/bjp.134.2.195.
The purpose of this study was to examine the validity of assessing pictures produced by acute schizophrenic subjects as a technique in differential diagnosis. It was hypothesized that art productions by schizophrenics differ from those both by other acute psychiatric patients and by 'normals'. Coloured slides were made from pictures produced in standardized conditions by three samples of each of thirty subjects. It was found that repetition of abstract forms was the only factor studied to be associated specifically with schizophrenia; whereas the presence of pictorial imbalance, overelaboration, childlike features, uncovered space, detail and colour variety were found to be associated with psychiatric admission irregardless of diagnosis. Doubt is cast on the use of art as a technique in differential psychiatric diagnosis.
本研究的目的是检验将急性精神分裂症患者创作的画作作为鉴别诊断技术的有效性。研究假设为,精神分裂症患者的艺术作品与其他急性精神病患者以及“正常人”的作品不同。从三十名受试者中各抽取三个样本,在标准化条件下创作的画作制成彩色幻灯片。结果发现,抽象形式的重复是所研究的唯一与精神分裂症有特定关联的因素;而画面失衡、过度雕琢、童趣特征、留白、细节和色彩多样性的存在则被发现与是否需接受精神科住院治疗有关,与诊断无关。人们对将艺术作为精神科鉴别诊断技术的应用提出了质疑。