Rao K P, Nair S S, Cobbold N, Naganathan N
Bull World Health Organ. 1966;34(4):589-604.
Culture examination is technically superior to direct microscopy in the diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis, but its practicability and relative importance in various phases of national tuberculosis control programmes in developing countries must be studied before culture facilities are provided on a large scale.Some operational factors affecting the efficacy of the culture method have been analysed in four studies conducted by the National Tuberculosis Institute, Bangalore. The results showed that an interval of up to 7 days between collection of specimens in the field and culture in the laboratory did not affect the yield of positive cultures, even though the specimens were stored and transported under field conditions. A higher proportion of positive cases was detected by culture than by direct microscopy, but the magnitude of the additional yield was dependent upon the procedure for selecting persons for sputum examination. In service programmes restricted to persons with symptoms who voluntarily attend diagnostic centres, the increased yield is too small to justify the introduction of culture examination. The method is substantially rewarding, however, in the evaluation of national control programmes, in changes of drug regimen consequent on altered bacteriological status, and in mass programmes for the early detection of infectious cases.
在肺结核诊断中,培养检查在技术上优于直接显微镜检查,但在大规模提供培养设施之前,必须研究其在发展中国家国家结核病控制规划各阶段的实用性和相对重要性。班加罗尔国家结核病研究所进行的四项研究分析了一些影响培养方法效果的操作因素。结果表明,即使标本在现场条件下储存和运输,从现场采集标本到实验室培养之间长达7天的间隔时间也不会影响阳性培养结果的产出。通过培养检测出的阳性病例比例高于直接显微镜检查,但额外产出的幅度取决于痰检人员的选择程序。在仅针对有症状且自愿前往诊断中心的人员的服务项目中,增加的产出过小,不足以证明引入培养检查的合理性。然而,该方法在国家控制规划评估、因细菌学状况改变而导致的药物治疗方案变更以及早期发现感染病例的大规模项目中具有显著价值。