Lindenbaum J, Greenough W B, Islam M R
Bull World Health Organ. 1967;37(4):529-38.
In a controlled trial of the effects of oral antibiotics in treating cholera in children in Dacca, East Pakistan, tetracycline was the most effective of 4 antibiotics tested in reducing stool volume, intravenous fluid requirement, and the duration of diarrhoea and positive stool culture. Increasing the duration of tetracycline therapy from 2 to 4 days, or increasing the total dose administered, resulted in shorter duration of positive culture, but did not affect stool volume or duration of diarrhoea. Only 1% of the children receiving tetracycline had diarrhoea for more than 4 days. Tetracycline was significantly more effective than intravenous fluid therapy alone, regardless of severity of disease.Chloramphenicol, while also effective, was inferior to tetracycline. Streptomycin and paromomycin exerted little or no effect on the course of illness or duration of positive culture. Therapeutic failures with these drugs were not due to the development of bacterial resistance.From these findings, tetracycline appears to be the drug of choice against Vibrio cholerae infection in children. Oral therapy for 48 hours is effective clinically, but is associated with 20% bacteriological relapses when the drug is discontinued; it is not known whether extending the therapy for a week or more would eliminate such relapses.
在东巴基斯坦达卡进行的一项关于口服抗生素治疗儿童霍乱效果的对照试验中,在减少粪便量、静脉补液需求、腹泻持续时间和粪便培养阳性持续时间方面,四环素是所测试的4种抗生素中最有效的。将四环素治疗时间从2天延长至4天,或增加给药总剂量,可缩短培养阳性持续时间,但不影响粪便量或腹泻持续时间。接受四环素治疗的儿童中只有1%腹泻超过4天。无论疾病严重程度如何,四环素都比单纯静脉补液治疗显著更有效。氯霉素虽然也有效,但不如四环素。链霉素和巴龙霉素对疾病进程或培养阳性持续时间几乎没有影响。这些药物治疗失败并非由于细菌耐药性的产生。根据这些发现,四环素似乎是治疗儿童霍乱弧菌感染的首选药物。口服治疗48小时临床有效,但停药时会有20%的细菌学复发;延长治疗一周或更长时间是否能消除此类复发尚不清楚。