Tulloch A J, Moore V
J R Coll Gen Pract. 1979 Dec;29(209):733-40.
A randomized controlled trial of geriatric screening and surveillance was undertaken on a practice population of 295 patients aged 70 years or more over a two-year period. In the screened group (145 patients) many social problems were found and a total of 380 medical conditions were reported during the study period, 144 (38 per cent) of which were previously undetected. Conditions found most frequently involved the circulatory, musculoskeletal and nervous systems; 67 per cent of the conditions found were manageable, half being improved and the remainder resolved completely.The screening programme was found to increase the use of social and health services but it did also decrease the expected duration of stay in hospital.Independent assessment of patients in the study and control groups at the end of the two-year period showed that the screening programme had made no significant impact on the prevalence of socio-economic, functional, and medical disorders affecting health.We formed the firm impression that the study patients were made more comfortable (by control of pain) and less disabled, although there was no unequivocal objective evidence of this. They were, however, kept independent for longer.The findings are discussed and a model of geriatric care is suggested combining conventional management on demand with comprehensive screening to identify the high-risk patients on whom care might need to be focussed.
在两年时间里,对295名70岁及以上的患者群体进行了一项老年筛查和监测的随机对照试验。在筛查组(145名患者)中发现了许多社会问题,在研究期间共报告了380种疾病状况,其中144种(38%)此前未被发现。最常发现的疾病涉及循环系统、肌肉骨骼系统和神经系统;所发现疾病的67%是可控制的,其中一半病情有所改善,其余的完全得到解决。研究发现,筛查项目增加了社会和卫生服务的使用,但也缩短了预期住院时间。在两年期结束时,对研究组和对照组患者进行的独立评估表明,筛查项目对影响健康的社会经济、功能和医疗障碍的患病率没有显著影响。我们形成了一个坚定的印象,即研究中的患者(通过疼痛控制)感觉更舒适,残疾程度更低,尽管没有明确的客观证据证明这一点。然而,他们保持独立的时间更长。对研究结果进行了讨论,并提出了一种老年护理模式,将按需常规管理与全面筛查相结合,以识别可能需要重点护理的高危患者。