Madden D L, Krezlewicz A, Gravell M, Sever J L, Tourtellotte W W
Neurology. 1978 Mar;28(3):295-9. doi: 10.1212/wnl.28.3.295.
Recent reports indicate that a multiple sclerosis agent (MSAA) has been isolated. This agent was detected in mice by a depression in the percentage of mouse polymorphonuclear neutrophils (PMNs). We attempted to repeat these studies using coded specimens. The test, itself, was extremely variable and difficult to reproduce. In the first study, three of three multiple sclerosis (MS) patients and one of two control patients' specimens showed some PMN depression. In a repeat study of these same samples, one of three MS patients and one of two controls were associated with PMN depression. With a second set of coded specimens, one of four MS patients, one of three patients with neurologic diseases, and none of three controls showed PMN depression. We were unable to confirm the presence of MSAA and conclude that the results were random.
最近的报告表明,一种多发性硬化症因子(MSAA)已被分离出来。通过小鼠多形核中性粒细胞(PMN)百分比的降低在小鼠中检测到了这种因子。我们试图使用编码样本重复这些研究。该测试本身极具变异性且难以重复。在第一项研究中,三名多发性硬化症(MS)患者的样本中有三个以及两名对照患者的样本中有一个显示出PMN降低。在对这些相同样本的重复研究中,三名MS患者中有一个以及两名对照中有一个与PMN降低有关。对于第二组编码样本,四名MS患者中有一个、三名神经系统疾病患者中有一个以及三名对照中无一显示出PMN降低。我们无法证实MSAA的存在,并得出结果是随机的结论。