Frequency of cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors to herpes simplex virus type 1 as determined by limiting dilution analysis.

The conditions for establishing a limiting dilution assay to measure cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors (CTL-P) against herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) were determined. Analysis by Poisson statistics demonstrated that the estimated frequency of HSV-1-reactive cells in the spleens of normal mice was less than 1/250,000. In contrast, mice immunized previously with infectious HSV-1 demonstrated a CTL-P frequency between 1/3,500 and 1/15,670. The generation of a maximum cytotoxic T lymphocyte response required that mice be primed in vivo with infectious virus. Immunization with inactivated virus either failed to elicit detectable CTL-P frequencies or gave frequencies markedly less than those induced with infectious virus. To obtain positive cultures, the responder cell population had to be exposed to stimulator splenocytes expressing viral antigens. Normal splenocytes without virus or normal splenocytes with T cell growth factor did not result in significant cytotoxicity. Split culture analysis comparing cytotoxicity against syngeneic and allogeneic virus-infected targets provided evidence for specificity, H-2 restriction, and the T cell nature of the CTL-P. It was determined that precursors were eliminated by treatment with anti-Thy 1, Lyt 2.1, or Lyt 1.1, indicating the CTL-P were Lyt 1(+)2(+) cells. Cytotoxicity was reduced after treatment of the responders with anti-Lyt 2 plus complement, which gave further evidence of the T cell nature of the cytotoxic T lymphocytes. These experiments demonstrated the feasibility of using the limiting dilution approach as a highly sensitive and quantitative means to measure the cell-mediated immune response to HSV-1 antigens.