Manek S, Rutherford J, Jackson S H, Turner P
Br Med J (Clin Res Ed). 1984 Nov 24;289(6456):1433-4. doi: 10.1136/bmj.289.6456.1433.
A questionnaire concerning views of hospital clinical staff was completed by 408 out of 542 staff (75%), comprising 214 medical staff of all clinical specialties, 106 first year clinical medical students, and 88 third year student nurses. On average 386 of 407 (95%) thought that blood pressure should be measured routinely in all inpatients but only 294 of 404 (73%) thought that this was appropriate for outpatients. Although 251 of 390 (64%) were taught to use the muffling of sounds (phase IV) as the diastolic blood pressure, only 219 of 406 (54%) actually used this phase alone. There were appreciable differences between the grades of staff in this respect, a small majority of most grades using phase IV. Roughly half (50 out of 102) of the medical student respondents were taught to use phase IV, but only 38 of 106 (36%) were actually using this phase. While only three out of 16 general practitioners were using phase IV diastolic blood pressure alone, the figure was 66 out of 88 (75%) for student nurses. The level of diastolic blood pressure at which clinicians would begin to treat a 50 year old asymptomatic man ranged from 90 to 121 mm Hg. When these figures were corrected to phase V values, assuming a 5 mm Hg difference between phases IV and V, the range was 85 to 116 mm Hg. Despite the general agreement among physicians interested in hypertension that the disappearance of sounds (phase V) should be used to denote diastolic blood pressure there is still considerable divergence of opinion among hospital medical staff.
542名医院临床工作人员中有408人(75%)完成了一份关于医院临床工作人员观点的调查问卷,其中包括214名各临床专科的医务人员、106名临床专业一年级医学生和88名三年级实习护士。平均而言,407人中有386人(95%)认为所有住院患者都应常规测量血压,但404人中只有294人(73%)认为这适用于门诊患者。尽管390人中有251人(64%)被教导将声音减弱(第四阶段)作为舒张压,但406人中只有219人(54%)实际仅使用此阶段。在这方面,不同职级的工作人员之间存在明显差异,大多数职级中有一小部分人使用第四阶段。大约一半(102人中有50人)的医学生受访者被教导使用第四阶段,但106人中只有38人(36%)实际使用此阶段。虽然16名全科医生中只有3人仅使用第四阶段的舒张压,但实习护士的这一数字为88人中有66人(75%)。临床医生开始治疗一名50岁无症状男性的舒张压水平范围为90至121毫米汞柱。假设第四阶段和第五阶段之间相差5毫米汞柱,将这些数字校正为第五阶段的值后,范围为85至116毫米汞柱。尽管对高血压感兴趣的医生普遍认为应使用声音消失(第五阶段)来表示舒张压,但医院医务人员之间仍存在相当大的意见分歧。