Goetz I E, Roberts E, Warren J
Am J Hum Genet. 1981 Mar;33(2):187-96.
We previously reported that skin fibroblasts with Huntington disease (HD) grew to higher maximal densities and, at early culture passages, attained more population doublings per week than did fibroblasts from control individuals. We also noted that HD cells were smaller and that larger colonies developed from single cells. In view of discrepant results reported from replications of the above studies, we undertook extensive blind studies with 10 coded pairs of HD and control cells in which all the skin biopsies were obtained by the same method, and the HD and control cells were grown identically at all times. No significant differences were found between HD and control cells in any of the above parameters in the current study. Some of the possible reasons for our failure to reproduce the previous results are discussed, chief among them may be the different treatment to which the HD and control cells might have been subjected prior to coming to our hands and the utilization of skin samples from different regions of the body.
我们之前报道过,患有亨廷顿舞蹈症(HD)的皮肤成纤维细胞能生长到更高的最大密度,并且在早期传代培养时,每周实现的群体倍增次数比对照个体的成纤维细胞更多。我们还注意到,HD细胞更小,并且单细胞能形成更大的集落。鉴于上述研究的重复实验得出了相互矛盾的结果,我们对10对编码的HD和对照细胞进行了广泛的盲法研究,其中所有皮肤活检均通过相同方法获取,并且HD和对照细胞在任何时候都以相同方式培养。在本研究中,HD和对照细胞在上述任何参数上均未发现显著差异。文中讨论了我们未能重现先前结果的一些可能原因,其中主要原因可能是HD和对照细胞在落入我们手中之前可能受到的不同处理,以及使用了来自身体不同部位的皮肤样本。