Işcan M Y, Loth S R, Wright R K
J Forensic Sci. 1984 Oct;29(4):1094-104.
The determination of age at death is an important part of physical and forensic anthropology. Techniques now in use vary from direct observation of a bone to microscopic examination of a given segment. This study introduces the sternal end of the rib as a new site for age estimation by direct observation. The sample consisted of 118 white male ribs of verified age, sex, and race. The ribs were assigned to one of nine phases (0 through 8) based on changes noted at the costochondral junction. These included the formation of a pit, its depth and shape, configuration of the walls and rim surrounding it, and the overall texture and quality of the bone. Statistical analysis indicated that these changes were age related. It was further revealed that metamorphosis was most rapid and uniform from the mean age of 17 to 28 years (Phases 1 through 4). The rib morphology was more varied after age 39 (Phase 5) resulting in a wider range for the predicted age. Our study concluded that the sternal rib end may yield a similar degree of accuracy to the pubic symphysis and perhaps better than that for cranial sutural closure. Our technique also enables the forensic scientist to use the rib for corroboration with age estimations obtained by traditional methods.
死亡年龄的确定是体质人类学和法医人类学的重要组成部分。目前使用的技术从对骨骼的直接观察到对特定部位的显微镜检查各不相同。本研究引入肋骨胸骨端作为通过直接观察估计年龄的新部位。样本包括118根已核实年龄、性别和种族的白人男性肋骨。根据肋软骨交界处观察到的变化,将肋骨分为九个阶段(0至8)之一。这些变化包括凹坑的形成、其深度和形状、围绕它的壁和边缘的形态,以及骨骼的整体质地和质量。统计分析表明,这些变化与年龄有关。进一步发现,从平均年龄17岁到28岁(第1至4阶段),变形最为迅速且一致。39岁以后(第5阶段),肋骨形态变化更大,导致预测年龄范围更广。我们的研究得出结论,肋骨胸骨端的准确性可能与耻骨联合相似,甚至可能优于颅骨缝闭合的准确性。我们的技术还使法医能够利用肋骨来佐证通过传统方法获得的年龄估计。